Good morning all. I'm a UK buyer and I sold a 1980s transformer toy with its box through the GSP. The box had a tear in it, which I described in the auction and put a photograph of the damage in the auction also. The item was sold as 'used', not 'new'. A buyer in Australia won the item. He has received the item, and clicked to return the item. in the return he sent me a message saying "Box is torn in bad way not shown in pictures so must be damaged on delivery" and sent a photo of the tear. It is precisely the same tear that I called out and put photos of in the auction. To my eyes, I've been 100% clear, transparent and honest about the condition of the item and he has received it in the condition it was auctioned at. Ebay has sent me a message saying "There's something wrong with the item your buyer's received, so they'd like to return it" and my options seem to be: if it was damaged by the shipping (it wasn't - item damage is as sold) I wait and it gets escalated to ebay Accept the return - Contact the buyer to work out return postage details. Wait to get the item back before you refund the buyer. (item sold for £36 UK pounds) Give a full refund - You can fully refund the buyer to close this request. The buyer keeps the item Offer a partial refund - You have one chance to offer an amount. The buyer keeps the item. Send the buyer a message - You can reply to the buyer. I'm keen not to end up with a defect or poor feedback - I'm at 100% positive, and take my buyer happiness very seriously. I'm also very keen not to end up out-of-pocket, as it's not a high value item and shipping back from Australia will likely be expensive. My auction also stated "Returns policy - Return policy details - The seller won't accept returns for this item." (Ebay's words - I just checked the checkbox) None of the above seem to fit my case - is my best option to contact the buyer, point out that the damage he himself has sent evidence of was clearly called out in the auction (and the auction contains a corroborating photograph) - but if he persists with the return, will ebay support me? If anyone's got any previous experience with this, I'd appreciate it.
... View more