30-06-2025 11:24 AM
Hi Firstly thanks for taking some time to read this.
i sold an item valued at £500, I accepted £425.
the buyer is saying I sent the wrong item.
(they took the original item & replaced it with something else)
i am 100% certain I enclosed the right item.
I am very upset by this, I pride myself on my eBay, I have a wonderful relationship with buyers & sellers.
eBay have told me to send a return postage label.
I am 100% disputing this.
If I do what eBay have said, does that mean I don’t get paid & the buyer runs off with the original item for free?
01-07-2025 8:49 AM
I do consignment sales for customers who want to sell their cards, I usually take them to card shows where the sales can be done in person.
Selling on behalf of someone is not against any eBay rules as far as I know as long as the sale is legit.
I'm happy to discuss my processes for this if you want some reassurance
07-07-2025 12:13 PM
Hi,
update
tbe buyer has returned the wrong item (as I knew he would)
eBay refunded him the second the package was delivered. They have taken my available balance from eBay & tried to take the payment from my card (which there aren’t any funds in).
I have obviously opened a claim saying the wrong item was received by me.
its an absolute joke.
i have reported the card to PSA, ACE, MGC and reported it to online fraud team.
I have also ordered some ‘tamper proof stickers’ to place on every future parcel.
feeling really really defeated ☹️
07-07-2025 12:30 PM
Let us know how it goes.
07-07-2025 12:43 PM
@user_25 wrote:
eBay refunded him the second the package was delivered.
That's unusual; the seller is usually afforded time to report a problem.
@user_25 wrote:
I have obviously opened a claim saying the wrong item was received by me.
You need to file a report with Action Fraud who will give you a reference number and a report; do this first.
In the case - if it still open - there should be a "Report a problem" link; can you see that link?
07-07-2025 4:12 PM
It’s case closed, however I have raised it with eBay. Post arrived to work at 10.15, 10.26 eBay emailed me saying we have refunded the buyer on your behalf.
yes I have opened an action fraud & been given a case number.
i have asked eBay what seller protection is in place & as I say I’ve reported the return item as different to what I sent.
07-07-2025 4:44 PM
@user_25 wrote:It’s case closed, however I have raised it with eBay. Post arrived to work at 10.15, 10.26 eBay emailed me saying we have refunded the buyer on your behalf.
yes I have opened an action fraud & been given a case number.
i have asked eBay what seller protection is in place & as I say I’ve reported the return item as different to what I sent.
When you reported the return did you use the "Report a problem" link? It sounds to me like you clicked this link too soon. When you click that link the automated return case is closed and a new case is opened against the buyer (it still looks like one case). However, if you clicked that link before you received the item back eBay likely waited to see what the tracking was showing then refunded the buyer once the tracking indicated a delivery scan. You should not have clicked that link until you had received the different item back; once you received the item you first needed to file a report with Action Fraud then used that "Report a problem" link giving the reference number from AF and attaching the AF report.
At the bottom of the last message you received from eBay there should be a link to appeal their decision. You need to click that link and do the following:
08-07-2025 5:21 PM
Hi Bathrooms!
thank you for this! I appealed it and providing my action fraud reference number they have agreed to ‘refund’ me.
im still very cross about the buyer, as he had the card & the refund, but, at least I have got what I was owed.
i really appreciate your guidance & time on this. It’s really really appreciated.
09-07-2025 9:52 AM
Don't forget to add them to your blocked buyer list if you haven't already.
09-07-2025 10:45 AM
Glad you got this sorted out, it's a sucky situation to be in
04-10-2025 2:15 AM
I'm so sorry this has happened to you - it is so unfair, that nefarious characters with no morals or scruples can even attempt, never mind get away with something like this - it is literally criminal, and, along with the financial issue, it has created for you a world of stress, debility and extra work - creating for the thief, probably holiday money. I've never sold on eBay, and with the changes to the way it all works, along with the deluge of rogue buyers, that I have read on this forum are increasingly scamming sellers left and right, I never will.
I'm at the stage now, as a buyer, where I can't take any more of the rogue sellers - I've been burned, this last 12 months, by all sorts of shenanigans (these, just two of them: one seller messed me around with a combined postage invoice, then requested I buy off-platform, on Vinted, instead, so they could avoid eBay fees and charge more for the items - not my fault the start bids were ridiculousy low and there was zero competition; another, has sent me the wrong figurine - I told them I do not have a printer, that I want a postage-paid returns label posting to my home, so I can send this wrong, tatty thing back for a refund - they ignored me, I had to open a case, which was closed, return process started, with me, yes, you guessed it, being expected to print off a label, when I told the seller AND eBay, I do not have a printer), I'm pretty much done with eBay now.
I used to be mad for eBay, now, it just makes me mad. The good guys, nowadays, are too few, and too far between. I've found the only sure way to not get scammed, is buy off a charity - I've NEVER been stung by a charity eBay seller. I'm going to start going to charity shops and car-boot sales again - I fancy the odd record fair is in my future, too. I now want to be able to assess an item in person; I want to see, feel, and smell the thing, before I part with my cash. That way, I can be absolutely sure of what I'm getting - I'll be taking it home, sold-as-seen, with no further work necessary, and I won't have to mess about with the bot-driven eBay process for dealing with issues inflicted by rogues - it is not robust enough. Actually, I'd say, it's not fit for purpose. I miss eBay, how it used to be. I really do. I won't miss what it has become.
I feel for you, and I dearly hope that you never get burned like that again. I think the sage advice of someone here - sell low-value items on eBay, but the high-value items, take to a specialist dealer to sell for you, is the best I've read, thus far. Best of luck to you.