12-02-2025 11:56 AM
I made a sale on my personal account this morning for a set of headphones that I had listed at £59.95 with it set to auto accept offers over £50.00.
A buyer made an offer 10% below asking price, so £54.00 and as I have it set to auto-accept above £50.00 this was accepted, however, when the email for the order came through, I only receive £51.23 as the Buyer Protection Fee of £2.77 is INCLUDED in the offer price.
In my opinion, if the buyer has offer £54.00, I should receive the £54.00 and the BPF should be added to that.
Just be aware if you have offers, particularly on lower value items, as this change will make most low value offers pointless to sellers.
eBay seem to be on a path to self destruction, not giving a thought as to how their imbecilic changes affect real people 🤷♂️
16-08-2025 7:09 AM - edited 16-08-2025 7:09 AM
While I agree that the information is not well presented, consisting as it does of different views for buyer and seller in different places as well as including and excluding VAT, overall it does work as set out in the guidance.
Buyers pay the buyer protection fee as part of their agreement with ebay.
Good luck with Martin and TS though.
16-08-2025 5:27 PM
Hi, pinkrabbitprinces82,
You certainly seem to be on to something.
🤞🏻 you get some answers.
14-09-2025 5:59 AM
And yet nothing has been done to address this as its stila probleml
15-09-2025 6:24 PM
yes ebay are breaking their own policy, I wrote a long letter them here:-
Manager in charge (Formal serious Complaints)
eBay Commerce UK Ltd. ("ECUK")
1 More London Place,
London,
SE1, 2AF,
i got one reply via e-mail 2 weeks ago saying my letter has been passed onto a manager as requested on my letter, no further reply so 've told them I am going to trading standards via citizens advice tomorrow! as it's illegal for a company to break their own policy. we need more people to complain about, i tried first via their facebook page only to be told the buyers fee is included in the price, yet it is and supposed to be, when you see an item for buy it now it's not the orignal lower price the seller listed it at. I enclsoe a screen shot showing an item I had on sale i was listing it at £195, yet the buyer sees a price of £203.48, that be cause the fee has been worked out on the item price of £195 as a percentage as set out in their policy,
They charge the buyer 7% on any amount up to £20, then 4% or any portion from £20-£300 then 2% of any portion from £300-£4,000. that percentage is worked out on the item price and added to the listing price.
So the same should be said for sellers receiving offers as the offer is now the "price" they state the buyer pays the fee, and that the fee is added to the "price", yet I got an offer of £45 for an item but only recieevd £42.61p. they had clearly deducted the buyers fee off the offer of £45, yet if i had listed the item at £45 buy it now, i would receive the full buy it now sale of £45, any fees would again be on top of that 345, not included. they kept insisting the offer includes the buyers fees, i was trying to explain back "no" "the buyers fee has to be worked out as percentage as per ebay policy on the main offer price, before they can say it's been added or included in the price! i have sent a story to money saving expert, made a post on the mse forum, i have a post on here but had little attention.
15-09-2025 6:26 PM
s ebay are breaking their own policy, I wrote a long letter them here:-
Manager in charge (Formal serious Complaints)
eBay Commerce UK Ltd. ("ECUK")
1 More London Place,
London,
SE1, 2AF,
i got one reply via e-mail 2 weeks ago saying my letter has been passed onto a manager as requested on my letter, no further reply so 've told them I am going to trading standards via citizens advice tomorrow! as it's illegal for a company to break their own policy. we need more people to complain about, i tried first via their facebook page only to be told the buyers fee is included in the price, yet it is and supposed to be, when you see an item for buy it now it's not the orignal lower price the seller listed it at. I enclsoe a screen shot showing an item I had on sale i was listing it at £195, yet the buyer sees a price of £203.48, that be cause the fee has been worked out on the item price of £195 as a percentage as set out in their policy,
They charge the buyer 7% on any amount up to £20, then 4% or any portion from £20-£300 then 2% of any portion from £300-£4,000. that percentage is worked out on the item price and added to the listing price.
So the same should be said for sellers receiving offers as the offer is now the "price" they state the buyer pays the fee, and that the fee is added to the "price", yet I got an offer of £45 for an item but only recieevd £42.61p. they had clearly deducted the buyers fee off the offer of £45, yet if i had listed the item at £45 buy it now, i would receive the full buy it now sale of £45, any fees would again be on top of that 345, not included. they kept insisting the offer includes the buyers fees, i was trying to explain back "no" "the buyers fee has to be worked out as percentage as per ebay policy on the main offer price, before they can say it's been added or included in the price! i have sent a story to money saving expert, made a post on the mse forum, i have a post on here but had little attention. i've also gone to bbc radio 4 with my story.
15-09-2025 8:38 PM
I don't see how you can claim that eBay is breaking its own policy. The Buyer Protection Fee help page for sellers states quite clearly that the buyer's offer price includes the BPF and they have even provided a worked example:
'If a buyer bids on an auction or makes an offer on a listing, the Buyer Protection fee is included in their auction or offer amount, so they know exactly how much they'll pay if they win the auction or if their offer is accepted. The seller sees the auction or offer price without the fee, so they know exactly how much they'll receive.'
Buyer makes an offer on a UK-based private seller's listing | |
Buyer offer price (includes Buyer Protection fee of £10.29) | £250 + postage |
Offer price that seller sees | £239.71 + postage |
Seller earnings* | £239.71 |
I do agree that the way it is worded when the seller receives the offer is still a little confusing, especially in the example that you have provided. It would be better if it just showed:
Item price: £45.00 excluding BPF:
Buyer's offer: £42.61 excluding BPF.
Other than that no one is actually losing out in any way as you and many others seem to think. It is just set up on eBay a little different to other sites:
On Vinted, for example, buyers are asked to enter the amount excluding the BPF. Vinted then calculates the BPF to arrive at the total amount to be paid by the buyer. If the buyer is happy with that amount then that is then submitted as the offer.
Wheras, on eBay the buyer is simply asked to enter the total amount they wish to pay.
If eBay was to do the same as Vinted then the buyer would simply enter a lower amount to arrive at the total they wish to pay, so the net result would be just the same. Granted they may not enter such an exact amount as £42.61 but instead round up or down slightly but I can't see that that would really make much difference.
16-09-2025 6:25 AM
no this is the policy on a buy it now price the buyer fee is worked out on the item "PRICE" as percetnage then added to the base sellerrs "price" https://www.ebay.co.uk/help/selling/selling/pricing-items/buyer-protection-information-sellers?id=55... ( we now add a Buyer Protection fee to the item price, which is paid by the buyer to eBay)
The Buyer Protection fee is calculated as:
so if sell an item for buy it now £195, the buyer sees a buy it now price of £203.48 (see screen shot) this is because the fee has been worked out as a percentage on my listing price of £195, £8.48 buyers fee has been added onto my orignal price of £195. buyer pays £203.48 plus any postage costs on top. I still receiev the £195 i listed it as.
with an offer if i receive an offer of £195, that offer now becomes the "price" remebr they say it's "ADDED TO THE PRICE" but yet i'm not receiving £195 I would receive much less than the offer.
i did a video as well loaded on my youtube channel to prove what's going on and there's also a glitch with offers explained end of my video, and example, it's clear ebay are breaking the policy on not adding the fee to the offer submitted.
i did an example with help of my mum on her account of if i listed a doll for £150 buy it now, as explained above i'd receive £150, but when somebody submits an offer of £150, i'd only receive. £143.58. no I don't now about you, but since when does anybdoy send an offer of a very odd amount like that? you wouldn't you usually would offer £150.or £148, or may the odd 50p. £143.58 was NOT the orignal "offer price" i proved in my video the buyer offered £150, so what is happening is the buyers fee of ££6.42 was NOT being "ADDED" to the "OFFER PRICE" of £150 as per their policy explaining how they work out the fee, it's supposed to be added on top of the "price after it has been worked out. only then can they say it has been added to and included in the price. what they have done is taken the £6.6.42 off the offer price of £150 and i'm left with £143.58. yes
Yet if i list it buy it now at £150 with NO OFFERS and somebody buys it now at £150 they would see a higher price their end of £156.60 which has had the buyers fee added to my original price of £150 so then the fee has been worked out on my asking price of £150 and added tot he £150 then and only then can they say it's included in the price the buyer sees. i said to ebay that's crazy so if i receiev an offer i'm paying the buyers fee as i've proved it has been taken off the offer submitted to me. but yet if I listed at buy it now price of that same offer amount submitted, i'd receive the full amount, but with an offer i'm not receiving the full amount. therefore ebay seem to be breaking their onn policy on how they work out and added the buyers on offers.
thefre is only one policy their specify as given link above, they DON'T specify two policy's one for offers and one for buy it now price in regards to the buyers fee. think you need to read the policy and how its suppose dot be worked out before you say "how can i say ebay are not following policy. i have submitted my concerns to main stream media and will go trading stnards today, i told them in my letter I would do this if not reimbursed for being charged the buyers fees.
here's my video for proof of what is going on and the glitch with offers.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CxgJB-AFEU&t=176s
16-09-2025 7:55 AM
7 months on and you can still only describe the BPF as a stealth seller’s fee. Plain and simple
16-09-2025 11:46 AM
It all seems very transparent now, so I am not sure what eBay is doing to break their policy
When you make an offer, before you confirm, it shows you your offer and what the seller will get, and if a seller accepts an offer it will tell seller what they will get before accepting - unless from someone outside UK then there will be the fees taken AFTER you've accepted offer, which is annoying, but it's probably always been like that.
A problem that does arise is when a buyer sends a message and says "will you accept £20?"; then they send an offer for £20 but of course it's less than £20. The best way forward, if they can't make the complicated calculation, or go through trial & error until they get it right, is to say to the seller to put in their offer and you will send counter offer that means it's £20 for you the seller.
What I don't know, is if I have a minimum amount on an accept offers listing, whether that will be my price not the buyers with BPF - I've not had an example of that and I can't really test it out!
And although it feels at times as if sellers are being charged the buyer protection fee, they are not.
(the first time I saw an offer when buyer protection fee came in, it wasn't clear and my father got less than the offer, but since then it has been very clear)
16-09-2025 4:32 PM
It gets weirder. Today I listed an item. Set the price to £30 buy it now. When I clicked next. The price changed to £28.17 ‘seller receives ’ and £30 ‘buyer pays’. I had to go in and manually change it.
Also listed some DVDS for £5 a while ago. Item page obvs added on buyer protection fee. My buyer sent me an offer for £5, guess they didn’t want to pay it.
It’s pretty clear who’s paying for the BPF .
i don’t mind , don’t expect a service for nothing, just sick of eBay sending me emails telling me it’s free to sell.
16-09-2025 7:37 PM
Yet another reason on my long list why ecrap is to be avoided
18-09-2025 5:38 AM