26-06-2024 5:41 PM
This is as clear as mud to me. Been to the gov. advice website and various others.
How does a 1972 poster fit in to this process?
It's not an exempt category.
Advise buyers this item is for viewing only ?
My initial reaction, sadly, to to switch EU and NI off.
Jo
26-09-2024 1:52 PM
"then you'd need to identify or appoint a responsible person that is based in the EU/NI. "
But I understand various health, saftey and operation details must still be supplied. The 'responsible person' is to be there to receive product recalls or to accept returns - oh and receive writs when a consumer wants to sue! Is the responsible person scheme free? Of course not. It is a scheme designd to levy an 'access to market' fee from small businesses and micro traders. EU will be banking on billions of continued funds flowing from the UK after the fines for voting no run out, they're in for a shock! They are also expecting to reduce imports being replaced with internal sales. They are again in for a shock there too. The second hand and widget seller base is very underdeveloped in the EU.
For specialist widgets and second hand spares for repairs, it will likely be the case EU buyers finding the specialist items using VPN on Google linking to eBay and then flying over on a cheapo flight to collect in person. A rare 70s Cortina headlight? I bet ya there will be lots of 'collection in person flights' in the future.
If eBay do atempt to act quasi-judicial onbehalf of the EU, then they will be bankrupt before the end of the next quater after December. Any online platform that attempts to enforce this EU law within the UK will go the same way. And I can see very serious unrest in NI as the reality that they have been annexed like Crimea was sinks in as an observable reality. This is going to end in tears.
26-09-2024 2:33 PM
The TSS also advised they would be responsible for the safety of goods being moved from GB to NI but as I now understand it this has absolutely nothing to do with GPSR requirements. They were solely referring to the entry summary declaration (ENS) which has a declaration box but this is concerned with things that absolutely should not be carried by Royal Mail nor a courier such as firearms, explosives, hazardous/radioactive substances etc. I'm pretty sure @maggna is correct and the TSS will not be able to provide the role of a NI responsible person.
I need to take a step back to basics to make sure my head is as far round this as it can be with the volume of information flowing. I'd appreciate your thoughts...
The UK government post Bexit have establishing the Windsor Framework - approved as far as I can understand by the EU. As we have a new goverment they have delayed the implementation of the Windsor Framework until 31st March 2025 don't quite understand why or what can actually now be changed.
Since BREXIT / Jan 21 goods via carier moved to NI have been covered under temporary measures and these remain in place until the Windsor Framework is introduced.
When the Windsor Framework is introduced goods being moved to NI will have to be shipped by TSS registered traders and TSS registered couriers.
The couriers will handle the bulk of paperwork/ submissions to TSS. Traders will have to complete some form of contents information digitally to couriers including their TSS number and will require to be registered with TSS to show UK operations and business goods movement falls under the Windsor Framework.
Entry Summary Declarations will be required for all goods under Windsor Framework - see below. These will most frequently for online sellers like ourselves using carriers, be carrier completed.
https://www.nicustomstradeacademy.co.uk/pdf/checklist-trader-standard-goods/
As NI is part of UK, goods shipped within the internal UK market are not subject to EU laws. Goods shipped under the Windsor Framework are acknowledged to be traded solely within the UK internal market.
As part of the Windsor Framework there is an option to not pay duties in NI. Goods need to be declared as not at risk of being traded into EU -that they're shipped for the sole use of NI users. To declare them not at risk, avoid excess EU paperwork and customers having to pay duties traders need to register with the UKIMS (UK Internal Market Scheme) which should give yet another account number that goes to the carrier (Royal Mail for me) and means, I hope, that less paperwork is completed by trader, courier and no hassle to end NI based customer.
I think at end of day our bit as small traders to NI will be a digital form similar to the CN22 with a box for TSS and a box for UKIMS number (I'm guessing one gets issued). It appears from NICTA that most steps and admin are carrier handled for standard goods from registered traders.
GPSR is for goods traded into Europe, NI is treated as Europe for customs purposes unless goods are shipped under UKIMS where they're declared for UK end use only and therefore don't.
So GPSR doesn't always apply.
As the temporary measures for shipment by carier are still legally inplace, until the Windsor Framework is in place, I can't understand how GPSR can/ will/ is likely to be enforced - other than by eBay who appear to be jumping the gun at a major cost to their own trade.
26-09-2024 3:50 PM - edited 26-09-2024 3:50 PM
@ojewellery wrote:
When the Windsor Framework is introduced goods being moved to NI will have to be shipped by TSS registered traders and TSS registered couriers.
The couriers will handle the bulk of paperwork/ submissions to TSS. Traders will have to complete some form of contents information digitally to couriers including their TSS number and will require to be registered with TSS to show UK operations and business goods movement falls under the Windsor Framework.
Entry Summary Declarations will be required for all goods under Windsor Framework - see below. These will most frequently for online sellers like ourselves using carriers, be carrier completed.
The role of the TSS is to submit an entry summary declaration (ENS) which is a relatively short form. Royal Mail, parcel couriers and most hauliers will be making the declaration using information supplied to them by the trader. I can't see any reason a B2C retailer would also need to register with the TSS as they are not going to be able to provide any more information than the carrier already has.
@ojewellery wrote:
As NI is part of UK, goods shipped within the internal UK market are not subject to EU laws. Goods shipped under the Windsor Framework are acknowledged to be traded solely within the UK internal market.
No, that isn't correct. The Windsor Framework is intended to prevent a hard land border between Northern Ireland and the Republic (Eire). Part of the solution was to effectively leave Northern Ireland in the EU's customs union meaning goods sold in or to Northern Ireland must comply with EU harmonisation (including safety) legislation. The only products this doesn't apply to are those that fall under the remit of the Northern Ireland Retail Movement Scheme (NIRMS) which covers agri-food products.
The "green lane" allows goods to be sent to consumers in Northern Ireland with no customs checks, duties nor EU VAT being applied as these goods will not be deemed at risk of passing over the border. However, the green lane system does not preclude the GPSRs - eBay and all other online marketplaces will still be required to obtain the product compliance information required under those regulations.
26-09-2024 6:03 PM
Been following this with much interest - it is our intention to continue selling to the EU and NI. However everything we sell is second hand and ranges in date of manufacture from 1975-2020. However we are confused about an apparent difference in what ebay is saying and what the legislation seems to say.
"The new GPSR does not prevent the sale of products which are in conformity with the GPSD and are placed on the market before 13 December 2024."
Vs
"Once the GPSR takes effect, non-compliant listings may be hidden from buyers in the European Union (EU) and Northern Ireland. This means buyers won’t be able to view or purchase these listings, and to make them visible again, you’ll need to revise them by adding the necessary information."
"If you’re a business seller listing new and second-hand products that are in scope of the GPSR in the EU and Northern Ireland, you’ll need to include the following information in your listings: etc etc"
So ebay seems to be saying the GSPR information is mandatory, but the rules seem to say that anything that complied with the 2001 GSPD regulations is not covered by GSPR and is fine to continue selling.
So we are left wondering a few questions:
Do items which were sold in the EU between 2001-2024 need to comply with the GSPR data entry requirements on ebay - if so why?
What about items that pre date the 2001 regulations?
Surely the GSPR rules only apply to items which are first sold post 13/12/24 - which means items that do not currently exist on the market at all?
26-09-2024 7:34 PM
@4_bathrooms wrote:
@ojewellery wrote:
When the Windsor Framework is introduced goods being moved to NI will have to be shipped by TSS registered traders and TSS registered couriers.
The couriers will handle the bulk of paperwork/ submissions to TSS. Traders will have to complete some form of contents information digitally to couriers including their TSS number and will require to be registered with TSS to show UK operations and business goods movement falls under the Windsor Framework.
Entry Summary Declarations will be required for all goods under Windsor Framework - see below. These will most frequently for online sellers like ourselves using carriers, be carrier completed.
The role of the TSS is to submit an entry summary declaration (ENS) which is a relatively short form. Royal Mail, parcel couriers and most hauliers will be making the declaration using information supplied to them by the trader. I can't see any reason a B2C retailer would also need to register with the TSS as they are not going to be able to provide any more information than the carrier already has.
I think carriers are unable to verify that UK business' are registered UK business'. Thats a required element of the Windsor framework. Chinese/ other country sellers can't use UK fulfilment as a way into NI/ EU via UK carriers. The trading business shipping to NI using TSS and the Windsor Framework needs to be UK registered hence have a UK gov TSS number.
@ojewellery wrote:
As NI is part of UK, goods shipped within the internal UK market are not subject to EU laws. Goods shipped under the Windsor Framework are acknowledged to be traded solely within the UK internal market.
No, that isn't correct. The Windsor Framework is intended to prevent a hard land border between Northern Ireland and the Republic (Eire). Part of the solution was to effectively leave Northern Ireland in the EU's customs union meaning goods sold in or to Northern Ireland must comply with EU harmonisation (including safety) legislation. The only products this doesn't apply to are those that fall under the remit of the Northern Ireland Retail Movement Scheme (NIRMS) which covers agri-food products.
The "green lane" allows goods to be sent to consumers in Northern Ireland with no customs checks, duties nor EU VAT being applied as these goods will not be deemed at risk of passing over the border. However, the green lane system does not preclude the GPSRs - eBay and all other online marketplaces will still be required to obtain the product compliance information required under those regulations.
The following is from: https://www.nicustomstradeacademy.co.uk/overview-of-windsor-framework/
I can't get my head around if we are declaring low checks on goods from not at risk categories the EU has any jurisdiction. Everything UK side I read implies that the TSS and UKIMS are all about keeping trade open between GB and NI.
This is also written in the NICTA (Northern Ireland Customs and Trade Accademy)FAQ on UKIMS (UK Internal Market Scheme):
This is closer to what @4_bathrooms talked about many moons ago when things were about as unclear as they are now!
If the TSS are our indirect customs representative solely for NI doesn't that circumvent the appointed person NI for GPSR for goods shipped solely to NI? If it does - I can't even work out if thats a stretch anymore, then for low risk products like our poster right at start of thread there aren't a lot of other things needed to meet the documentation requirements and trade can continue.
I'm now having the, prescribed by the TSS representative I spoke to this morning, glass of wine and sitting on the fence on registering for UKIMS.
27-09-2024 9:52 AM
Hi, I also sell similar items, now its 3 months on from your post and I find myself trying to figure the new rules out.
Did you decide on a course of action yet?
Any updates would be gratefully received.
thanks
27-09-2024 11:40 AM - edited 27-09-2024 11:41 AM
Yes thats what i think as i do not sell much in the areas that are afected EU and NI so
switching of EU and NI dose seem the best thing as sales would not realy be affected..
27-09-2024 1:03 PM
A number of the products I sell were manufactured in the EU and I have the manufacturer information.
They don't have hazard information, any product documents or product safety information.
Most of them are small bits of wiring for adding accessories to cars that can be used in multiple different ways, or plastic mounting parts.
If I enter the manufacturer, do I also need to add an Economic operator? If so can it be the same details as the manufacturer details and nothing else is needed?
Even if I add these, will my lisitings be hidden/removed due to the lack of product documents and safety information?
I've spent all morning trying to work out if I can maintain at least some of my lisiting being available in EU/NI and with time running out to add this information to all the listings, I'm starting to get quite frustrated with the lack of concrete information available on exactly what we need to provide.
27-09-2024 1:18 PM
It's an EU initiative and therefore likely to be so complicated by design so you give up and stop exporting anything to the EU. That way they believe they can protect sellers in their internal market from external cheaper/better products. Everything the EU does is about protectionism so ask yourself whether the amount you profit from exporting to the EU is worth it. Even if you succeed it is likely they will find a way to fine you for non-compliance of some obscure clause. I'd concentrate your resources on US/Canada instead!
27-09-2024 3:27 PM
I've turned off NI & EU in postage options. Will Ebay still hide my listings as there will be no GPSR boxes filled in on the listing?
There needs to be a Not Applicable box to tick.
29-09-2024 8:41 PM
I got that email on Thursday too. I've already removed EU GSP and NI, And, while away on holiday, decided to pull all my listings as our sales were rubbish anyway, yet eBay is STILL on our case.
Planning to try resisting this week so will be interesting to see what happens and if our listings are now visible!
29-09-2024 9:45 PM
30-09-2024 6:49 AM
@zancoindustrialautomation wrote:
Does anyone know anyway around this or other platforms that can be sold on
etc
There isn't a way around this. Even if you sold on your website - you would, in theory, still need to adhere to the requirements of GPSR. Any other platform should again, be doing similar things. If they aren't - then we will either find that the EU aren't actually able to police it, or they do and the platform will need to put in measures to comply.
Whether you agree or not with the EU policy - the only way around this is to campaign against it (one method of which is refusing to sell to those regions, and in turn annoying customers, who will make their, much more powerful voices heard)
30-09-2024 11:51 AM
@ojewellery wrote:
I think carriers are unable to verify that UK business' are registered UK business'. Thats a required element of the Windsor framework.
When a business sends goods to Northern Ireland they will be required to supply their (GB) EORI number to the carrier; that is how the carrier will confirm the sender is a business.
@ojewellery wrote:
Chinese/ other country sellers can't use UK fulfilment as a way into NI/ EU via UK carriers.
They can. The UK-established operator of the fulfilment house is obliged to register for VAT. As far as a carrier would be concerned the fulfilment house operator would be just another UK-established business.
@ojewellery wrote:The following is from: https://www.nicustomstradeacademy.co.uk/overview-of-windsor-framework/
I can't get my head around if we are declaring low checks on goods from not at risk categories the EU has any jurisdiction. Everything UK side I read implies that the TSS and UKIMS are all about keeping trade open between GB and NI.
The checks relate to goods not at risk of crossing the Irish border; they have nothing to do with EU product safety. The section that states "Goods being moved under the UK internal market system can do so on the basis of a reduced dataset with no requirement to submit a supplementary declaration and with no checks" is due to goods being moved for final sale to an NI consumer only requiring an entry summary declaration (ENS). Where a GB business ships something to an NI consumer the ENS will be completed by the carrier using the information given to them; there is no further information the GB business could supply.
The Northern Ireland Retail Movement Scheme (NIRMS) was introduced for the agri-food sector as it was realised that supermarkets (for example) could not legally import things like meat products, dairy products, fish, alcoholic beverages etc. into Northern Ireland as they would not meet EU requirements. Under the NIRMS agri-food products only have to comply with UK regulations; not those of the EU. That's why you will see prominent "NOT FOR EU" labelling on bulk supermarket packaging even in GB. Everything else (that isn't exempted by Annexe IX) is subject to the EU's GPSRs.
@ojewellery wrote:
If the TSS are our indirect customs representative solely for NI doesn't that circumvent the appointed person NI for GPSR for goods shipped solely to NI?
No, the TSS are only completing the ENS; they won't be anybody's responsible EU representative. As mentioned, all the "safety & security" information they have published relates only to the ENS which has nothing to do with the GPSRs.
30-09-2024 2:32 PM
Right - for what its worth, some of the moderators on the Amazon forum have finally attempted to answer the question of Northern Ireland and why you don't on Amazon UK need to do anything...
This is the response...
"Under GPSR, it's important to look at the order creation country, not the destination country as order creation country indicates the exact county where listing takes place. UK is not a part of EU therefore if the order is created on amazon.co.uk and sent to NI, that order doesn't need to comply with GSPR. If the order has been created in any other Amazon EU MPs and sent to NI, those listings will need to comply with GPSR. "
For what it is worth, I think amazon have completely got this wrong. Point 21 of the article states as follows...
In the case of a product offered for sale online or through other means of distance sales, the product should be considered to have been made available on the market if the offer for sale is targeted at consumers in the Union. In line with the applicable Union rules on private international law, a case-by-case analysis should be carried out in order to establish whether an offer is targeted at consumers in the Union. An offer for sale should be considered to be targeted at consumers in the Union if the relevant economic operator directs, by any means, its activities to a Member State. For the case-by-case analyses, relevant factors, such as the geographical areas to which dispatch is possible, the languages available, used for the offer or for ordering, means of payment, the use of currency of the Member State or a domain name registered in one of the Member States should be taken into consideration. In the case of online sales, the mere fact that the economic operators’ or the providers of online marketplaces’ interface is accessible in the Member State in which the consumer is established or domiciled is insufficient.
30-09-2024 3:25 PM
30-09-2024 3:43 PM
I was watching a UK resellers live YT discussion stream about this last night. (The Hills) it's an interesting watch. Many sellers are just going to leave things as they are and let eBay hide them.
I'd rather switch EU and NI off to, hopefully, ensure visibility.
Jo
30-09-2024 4:10 PM
30-09-2024 4:25 PM
Sorry I meant I've personally stopped selling to Europe and unfortunately switching NI off at the end of next month, to ensure visibility elsewhere. (US, Australia, Canada etc)
Jo
30-09-2024 4:33 PM