Garry, Lets do a sir Bobby study:)

[knockknock-66]

I have in my collection a lot of Sir Bobby Charlton signatures that i have got ip and also ttm, i have even visited his home in person and have photo's to prove the fact. Below i have listed several of Sir Bobby's signatures, i know for a fact that there is either a sec or a forgery within them. Can you or any one of the ttmforum members tell me which it/ or they are????? Here are the signatures.......

[allswell42]

CRACKIN SUBJECT PAUL I WOULDNT HAVE HAD A CLUE WELL DONE MATE

[norwichcity78]

Sorry Paul i didnt realise anybody else had said the very first photo in the post

[cobblered]

Thank you Paul, I have sent you a message mate.

Ralph.

[not_brazil_norn_iron]

Fascinating insight and in all honesty my judgement was down to the simple old process of elimination technique, i have looked at many's a 'untidy' Sir Bobby sig so the Good Luck sig which quite a few pointed towards as the culprit didn't bother me so i ruled that out, the blue montage comes from Kev as4u (as mentioned) so ruled that out, i have never seen a Sir Bobby with so many gaps like that card in #1 and was instanty suspicious but i thought it too obvious and then the later sigs added it was obvious you were just trying to throw everyone but i was onto you like a fly on a doggy dump and was having none of it, the world cup photo to me instantly stood out and as i've learned in years of collecting it was just 'gut feeling' (a hugely underrated mechanism in the world of autograph collecting i feel) and i just compared all the others with this one and ruled them out one by one using my own knowledge of Sir Bob sigs and things that i've learned to look out for from the experts and collectors like yourself

As for the prize, now now Paul, don't be sending me one of your more treasured valuable Sir Bobby pieces, you hear....;-):^O

[jason.r.wicks]

Great post and very interesting, well done to the winner, and guesser! 😉

[autografica]

Well done everyone, especialy to those who got the right answers.

If it has made some of you take a closer look at the way a signature is constructed, then that can only be a good thing.

I have just had a cancellation on the course, which leaves me one space open. So if either of the winners wants the space you can have it free of charge!

Its on the 10th June in Warrington, but get your skates on, i may change my mind!

Garry 

[knockknock-66]

Thank you for this Garry, i hope one of the lads can attend.

[autografica]

If they can't, then you can have it.

But i need to know by about Monday, so that it still gives me time to seel that one space.

Garry

[knockknock-66]

Will have to rain check the offer i'm afraid Garry, as much as i would like to attend i'm afraid i will be working.

I have already booked my hols for this year and have none left.

Thank you for the offer though:)

[cobblered]

#46. Garry, thank you very much for your kind offer but I am also restricted by work commitments so wouldn't be able to attend.

Ralph.

[autografica]

Just don't understand you guys, always working!

Garry

[wheel-lose]

thankyou paul and garry for your gestures and contribution on this thread,i am sure all the regulars appreciate it as much as i do

daz

[rjoh4352]

Superb thread. Really interesting read:-)