Hi eaten-fish, thanks for your post.
This is probably because your device was marked as a secure/trusted device in your PayPal account, so you might need to this from your PayPal account. You can try doing so from your settings in your PayPal account, or contacting PayPal directly.
Thank you,
Marco
Did you find your solution? Help other members by marking your problem as solved. Simply click on "Accept as solution" for the answer that helped you.