03-01-2025 1:05 PM
I’m a member for 14 years - I have today complained fiercely to EBay with regards to 4% + 75p charge on each item purchased as we all know this is a Back Door way of recovering the Seller Fees which were scrapped recently - Buyers already have adequate protection - as to payment 2 days after delivery - we’re at the mercy of Royal Mail to scan all items when collected (not guaranteed) 😡
Fellow members I urge you to let your disproval known - SHAME ON YOU Ebay😡😡
15-01-2025 8:47 PM
Agree with much of what you say, but this is nothing to do with 'the government'.
Maybe ebay will help the economy to grow unintentionally. Many of my recent purchases have not been as good as I had hoped and with increasing postage costs and now buyers fees I will be doing more shopping on the high street.
16-01-2025 3:54 AM
16-01-2025 8:47 AM
Charity shops know from experience what sells. They also know what sells better in certain branches than others e.g. jigsaws in one branch, teenage clothing in another.
Some bins that look like (and are) refuse bins are an ideal size for sorting things to take to another of their branches, but you don't know what the charity's refuse arrangements are e.g. call-for or infrequent or maybe even no council collection, do it in-house, employ a specialist firm ad hoc or regularly.
More and more charities also sell online. Either for online or even for most items online or not, they often have items properly opened and sorted elsewhere. Often a shop's staff do little or no sorting, only selling.
Items that are broken and need repair, including sewing alterations (the charity won't do those for you/buyer, why should they), are likely to be rejected straightaway. A donor can think "oh someone'll buy it, it's only got a small crack" but the reality is that no one will pay good money for it unless maybe if it's antique...would you if you were the buyer? (but it can be hard sometimes for a donor to fully "let go" of an item in their heart and to assess their items objectively.) And these days charities receive so much, not just from individuals, that they can afford to pick and choose - all that's good, as you want your chosen charity to maximise their takings, so there's no reason for me to feel offended if they reject an item, indeed I should feel bad if all I've made them do is act as a refuse disposal system when I should've done it myself.
If you do Gift Aid the charity keeps records for HMRC and send you a letter/email after a few weeks/months saying exactly how much your donation raised in total (no details but gives you an idea of what sells). Tip: don't forget to cancel your charity account when you retire!
A few charities accept working electrical items, if they have a volunteer qualified electrician available to certify them. They may even accept broken ones and the electrician will see if she/he can repair them. In such shops electrical goods often fly off the shelf. Charities tend not to advertise that they do this, however - find out by asking or by word of mouth.
A few charities sell, or even specialise (as with British Heart Foundation), in secondhand large furniture such as beds, (complete) lounge suites, wardrobes/chests of drawers often only if matching etc, sometimes with definite wear and tear, provided any relevant fire safety certificate is intact and still attached e.g. sofas. Popular with landlords of B&Bs or letting bedsits (especially in or near a university). Popular with donors. Such charities often have a free collection service but expect to send photos and maybe have an item rejected when the collector actually sees it.
16-01-2025 8:56 AM
Some charities accept electrical items if they have a volunteer qualified electrician to certify them. Charities don't tend to advertise this, though. Find out by asking or by word of mouth.
I have one 20 miles away (oh that's not far where I live) - very popular with donors and buyers alike.
16-01-2025 10:01 AM
@kateco1596 wrote:Agree with much of what you say, but this is nothing to do with 'the government'.
Maybe ebay will help the economy to grow unintentionally. Many of my recent purchases have not been as good as I had hoped and with increasing postage costs and now buyers fees I will be doing more shopping on the high street.
It's true you can't say for sure, but a lot of people here seem to have a view that this is all happening because eBay want to force private sellers to become business sellers... and that may be because eBay don't know how to deal with the digital sales reporting yet which the last government were absolute fools to sign up to because it's absolute nonsense.
It could land private sellers with a huge unexpected bill -or not??? And eBay's guide to what's acceptable differs from all the pedantic pencil necks claiming you're breaking the law if you list hundreds of items or making a profit on any item.
16-01-2025 10:27 AM
As for all the people not liking me telling the horrid truth about charity shops and trying to cover up the issue I would say then that if people want to donate stuff to charity just do a charity auction on here instead, then you know your diseased grandmothers ornaments have not just been slung in a dustbin.
Although.... what's the deal now with private sellers doing charity listings? Surely eBay are not charging buyers fees for that too? That will hit charities or be a headache for eBay to figure out unless you're giving 100% to charity, and even then as I found out once eBay took a percentage of the postage too! So it was actually costing me in the end.
16-01-2025 10:44 AM
@stimpson_jc wrote:As for all the people not liking me telling the horrid truth about charity shops and trying to cover up the issue I would say then that if people want to donate stuff to charity just do a charity auction on here instead, then you know your diseased grandmothers ornaments have not just been slung in a dustbin.
Although.... what's the deal now with private sellers doing charity listings? Surely eBay are not charging buyers fees for that too? That will hit charities or be a headache for eBay to figure out unless you're giving 100% to charity, and even then as I found out once eBay took a percentage of the postage too! So it was actually costing me in the end.
I do hope you meant to write deceased grandmothers.
16-01-2025 11:50 AM
A good way to find out 'the truth' about how a particular charity shop really deals with donations is to volunteer there.
And if you really think they should be selling everything that is donated, do a stint emptying their clothing/book banks! How much do you think the going rate is for a book with half the pages missing; a bag of dog mess; a bag of sick; garden rubbish, complete with lots of ants; used/unwashed underwear*? OK, I'm sure the last one has a value, but I doubt any charity would want to be involved in selling it!
* All amongst the joys we found when we emptied book banks for a charity.
More of our stuff will be going to the local charity shops now - we know how they work, so are happy to send stuff there.
16-01-2025 12:27 PM
16-01-2025 1:06 PM
@buffster1963 wrote:
@stimpson_jc wrote:As for all the people not liking me telling the horrid truth about charity shops and trying to cover up the issue I would say then that if people want to donate stuff to charity just do a charity auction on here instead, then you know your diseased grandmothers ornaments have not just been slung in a dustbin.
Although.... what's the deal now with private sellers doing charity listings? Surely eBay are not charging buyers fees for that too? That will hit charities or be a headache for eBay to figure out unless you're giving 100% to charity, and even then as I found out once eBay took a percentage of the postage too! So it was actually costing me in the end.
I do hope you meant to write deceased grandmothers.
🤣typical nit picker! These are the type of people I talk about who get sadistic pleasure from trying to make everyone think they've done something wrong all the time. They always come back with... "you've spelt something wrong".
Ok, so you're one of these people telling everyone they've got to become a business seller if they list a lot of items or make a bit of money -so how do you explain this statement from eBay?
>Ben sells his collection of trading cards for a profit. Even though he receives £18,000 and makes a profit of £2,900, he has a capital gains tax-free allowance, so there is no tax.
Annual eBay sales: £18,000
Annual eBay profit: £2,900
Taxes owed: £0
From this page: https://www.ebay.co.uk/sellercentre/selling/selling-online-and-hmrc
16-01-2025 1:33 PM
At risk of being a 'nit picker', that 'quote' refers to capital gains tax and not income tax.
The key is the 'sells his collection', that's not trading. So the only relevant tax is CGS, but ebay have even got that wrong.
The place to look for tax guidance is gov.uk.
16-01-2025 2:35 PM
@papso22 wrote:At risk of being a 'nit picker', that 'quote' refers to capital gains tax and not income tax.
The key is the 'sells his collection', that's not trading. So the only relevant tax is CGS, but ebay have even got that wrong.
The place to look for tax guidance is gov.uk.
What has eBay got wrong in that example, other than the fact that they should have made it clearer that it relates solely to Capital Gains Tax?
16-01-2025 2:50 PM
Absolutely! Why would anyone be poking in the bins at the back of the charity shop? I doubt they'd allow it so am assuming this is technically 'trespass'. Nothing is 'slung in a dustbin' if decent and saleable. Perhaps some people have unrealistic beliefs of what is saleable (if you don't want a faded shirt with smelly armpits and a big hole, why would anyone else? And if you sell me such an item on ebay I will open a return - it needs to go into textile recycling or the bin).
I would add to your list of received donations: Food-covered broken toys and a dirty nappy (unbelievable!)
I will definitely be donating to my local charity shop; like you I know how they work and have had emails of how much they've raised by selling my items. It's certainly more than I could raise on ebay.
16-01-2025 2:57 PM
i believe that most charity shops do not take underwear these days! The rest of what you say is right on, even going to car boots can make you cringe when you see the state of some of the stuff that is sold! A bit like on here when you see pictures of scrumpled up clothes (must admit i have had the odd creased ones but that is because they were new and i did not want to iron them - my relative just shoves her stuff in a bin bag to give to me to sort out!). I buy from people (car boot or ebay) who clearly show they care about what they are selling by presenting them in a good fashion.
16-01-2025 3:14 PM
@papso22 wrote:At risk of being a 'nit picker', that 'quote' refers to capital gains tax and not income tax.
The key is the 'sells his collection', that's not trading. So the only relevant tax is CGS, but ebay have even got that wrong.
The place to look for tax guidance is gov.uk.
Have you ever thought that you lot might be wrong just because of the way you want to read into everything? Because next year (or this year for those who had new accounts) after HMRC has received all the reports I'm sure it'll turn out the private sellers you pick on for silly little things for a start will have done nothing wrong.
You sound exactly like the regulars and corrupt ambassadors at MSE forum spreading misinformation just in a sad attempt to eliminate competition on eBay. Why are you even going through these conversations for private sellers telling them they should be business sellers when you're a business seller yourself?
16-01-2025 3:27 PM
@stripyzebras wrote:Absolutely! Why would anyone be poking in the bins at the back of the charity shop?
Because they're poor or homeless!?
Time to shut up about charity shop bins now please.
I only made the point because I don't want everyone rushing out at the same time to flood the charity shops only for it all to be wasted.... But there you go, for the sake of charity everyone wants to pretend that they never bin perfectly good stuff and they'll take absolutely anything to put it up for sale in their swanky high street charity shop. 😂🙄 yeah 4 sure.
16-01-2025 3:47 PM
"I don't want everyone rushing out at the same time to flood the charity shops only for it all to be wasted.... But there you go, for the sake of charity everyone wants to pretend that they never bin perfectly good stuff and they'll take absolutely anything to put it up for sale in their swanky high street charity shop"
Your personal experience differs vastly from mine. Rather than disagree with you, I'd suggest that charity shops are run differently and yours was lucky that it could be so picky in which items it choose to sell. Our local charity shops are requesting donations on the local community facebook page, so definitely not flooded with items. "Perfectly good stuff" will not be wasted (no-one's pretending ) and I wish the shop I volunteer in was "swanky". As for the poor and homeless; they can be a great place to buy and if you are homeless you will be thankful that there are charity shops raising money for the homeless; some of those hold back clothing to give directly to homeless people and also accept blankets and food donations.
"Time to shut up about charity shop bins now please"
Agree
16-01-2025 4:05 PM
Charities are always so grateful. 🤥 🤑
16-01-2025 5:40 PM
'......at MSE forum....'
Sheer curiosity ren : whats MSE ?
16-01-2025 6:01 PM
@lucy_farmer wrote:'......at MSE forum....'
Sheer curiosity ren : whats MSE ?
Money Saving Expert.