22-04-2025 8:16 PM
Good evening
I have been selling hatching eggs in here for 10 years and have just had my listings removed for policy violation. Has anyone else had this happen ? Also if I search hatching eggs and I can purchase from multiple buyers who is this the case ?
thankyou in advance
12-05-2025 1:02 PM
there are restrictions on eggs in some of the high risk areas where you need a licence etc to be able to move/sell them.
12-05-2025 1:08 PM
you must work for DEFRA with your comment! It is an over reaction by them as usual, never mind about the quality of the birds lives! Yes, i do live and have done all my life around and within the farming community and know full well how some things are devastating for the farmers and also what things DEFRA get a bee in their bonnet about. The hens have been housed for months now and up to last week the last case was at the beginning of April! Lets kill thousands of birds because 1 has a cold.... Good job they did not do that to us during covid.
12-05-2025 3:17 PM
@original-hatching*eggs*uk wrote:
I spoke to eBay customer service and they spoke to their management while I was on the telephone. what I said above in the previous message is what they told me. I would suggest if anyone has an issue I would recommend contacting them.
It is AI deciding the removal and outcome of sellers listings. This is What I said before, it came directly from eBay customer services.
I am only trying to help and for your info I have had one of my listings restored by eBay.
You don't have any current live listings though?
12-05-2025 3:46 PM
@original-hatching*eggs*uk wrote:I contacted eBay this morning and was told The issue was with Duck and Goose hatching eggs because the eBay AI is recognising them as Migratory or endangered species.
If an eBay customer service agent told me the sky was blue I'd still stick my head out of the window and check.
The published policy - which has not been written by AI - is unambiguous. It now states:
"Live animals - including pets, vertebrate and invertebrate feeder animals, and hatching eggs - aren’t allowed on eBay."
It doesn't matter if it is a hatching egg from a duck, goose, chicken or an alligator; hatching eggs are no longer allowed on eBay (UK).
12-05-2025 7:59 PM
I received this today (tried to reword my ad)
""""What activity didn't follow the policy
"Please understand that you listed live Fertilized egg for sale. With limited exception, live animals or pets are not permitted on eBay, due to various laws and regulations governing sale of animals and birds. Please don't relist such items.""""
Does anyone know what the "Limited exception" is? (However I hadn't worded it as "live fertilised egg")
S
13-05-2025 11:19 AM
"you must work for DEFRA with your comment!" - rather a strange comment to make however I don't work for DEFRA. I do however have qualifications in biological science and environmental sciences and worked in the food industry for 37 years in technical roles; so I do have some understanding of the issue and the subsequent problems related to it.
"... up to last week the last case was at the beginning of April! " - This show that the biosecurity measures introduced by DEFRA are working. Isolation and containment are the most effective control measures for any viral infection whether it be Bird Flu, Covid or even Ebola. Rapid spread of a virus like bird flu runs the risk of a more serious mutations developing. It could be argued that ineffective control measures are responsible for the ongoing bird flu epidemic in the USA which started over a year ago are responsible for the decimation of their flocks and the spread of the virus into dairy cattle; not to mention the one attributable death of a poultry worker from the virus.
"The hens have been housed for months now" - A virus can only be dealt with through the application of science, not emotion. I presume you know the symptoms through which a chicken will die from bird flu - that is the alternative. Wild birds and waterfowl are much more resilient to the virus than chickens and turkeys however they can act as a reservoir for the virus and don't display the severe symptoms; but they can readily infect domestic birds through contact. Hence the precautions.
"Lets kill thousands of birds because 1 has a cold.... Good job they did not do that to us during covid." - During Covid there was eventually an aid which could mitigate the effect - a vaccination. Unfortunately such a solution is not viable for commercial flocks of chickens, turkeys, geese, ducks etc however I am sure someone will be working on a solution involving an addition to their water or feedstuffs which will eliminate or mitigate the effects and consequences of this virus.
13-05-2025 11:32 AM
Inn February it was fine for eggs and some other creatures now its not what's changed its effectively stopping so many people on eBay.
13-05-2025 1:18 PM
13-05-2025 1:20 PM
13-05-2025 1:32 PM
What has changed is that previously ebay allowed the sale of hatching eggs and now they don't.
Playing around with listings of hatching eggs to circumvent the policy will get you into trouble.