User Activity

I purchased an item from a buyer on the same day I purchased an item from another buyer, different names different registered business addresses, when the items came they arrived at the same time with the same company same packages same name, as deli...
If I send an item signed for and the buyer contacts me and says she has not received it but it says it has been signed for with the date and time and i have got the address correct am i liable to pay her back. thank you