12-05-2025 8:28 PM
I just received 4 silver coins that I don't think are pure silver as advertised. There's a few apps to help test silver coins for weight size and sound but all 4 failed the test, while other coins I own passed. I sent the seller a message could he have bought some unreal ones and not releasing sold them on, stating that I wasn't accusing him of deliberately selling fake coins but he hasn't answered my message plus has now blocked me, have my fears been confirm. Thanks in advance.
12-05-2025 8:39 PM
12-05-2025 8:40 PM
If they failed the silver test you can send them back. Start a return on here:
https://www.ebay.co.uk/help/buying/returns-refunds/return-item-refund?id=4041
select "Doesn't match description" and escalate it to eBay after 3 complete working days.
12-05-2025 10:00 PM
Unless you can do extra testing, for eg by investing in a Sigma Metalytics verifier machine, I’d be really careful on eBay. Ping tests aren’t sufficient imo and it’s much safer to buy from reputable dealers.
13-05-2025 9:48 PM - edited 13-05-2025 9:50 PM
Difficult to tell unless we knew what the coins in question were.
Most silver coins are however genuine, mainly due to their low value ( Many don't make much above scrap weight ), so little point in faking them, unlike gold coins.
There are of course obvious exceptions, such as rare coins, high grade ones, significant dates, etc.
Also "Sound Tests" are rarely correct, size is however a good guide, as is weight, but on that point if they are very old coins can be a little out ( As in lighter ) due to wear over the years.
I suspose it really depends on how much you paid & if you purcased them as say for example an investment, but agai that only really applies to rarer coins.
If you have one near you try popping into a local coin dealer outlet or even a pawnbrokers ( Not a high street chain ) the little independant ones are the best, they usually have a vast knowledge of these sort of things & will probably be able to help you.
13-05-2025 9:59 PM - edited 13-05-2025 9:59 PM
Type american silver eagle 1oz coin into the eBay search. It is crazy how many £10/£15 fakes are for sale, the sad thing is people leave positive feedback thinking they are real. I’m not only singling out eBay, because it is rife everywhere.
To be balanced, there are also some very good sellers on eBay and you can find good deals but if anyone I knew asked me where to go I’d point them towards somewhere like Atkinsons or Chards to start with and stay away from eBay until they have the feel of what a real one is like.
14-05-2025 12:24 PM
Type american silver eagle 1oz coin into the eBay search. It is crazy how many £10/£15 fakes are for sale, the sad thing is people leave positive feedback thinking they are real.
I agree with you, but you have hit the nail on the head, with that comment.
Lets say a 1oz coin is "Troy" in weight, making it 31.1 grams.
The current scrap value of silver is approx 70p.
So 31.1gm's x 70p = £21.77 approx.
So when for sale for £10 to £15 that alone should tell any potential buyer they would be fake, or at the very least are looking through rose tinted specs.