help and opinions please

[robboh2006]

Iv been given this book by a friend as it belonged to his grandad and he didnt have an interest for it its an liverpool official centenary History 1892-1992, can anyone help on whether the signatures or any good please, it has been signed by 17 if they are good can anyone help with who has signed it, know a few but not sure on others.

http://img543.imageshack.us/img543/1785/liverpool001.jpg
http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/8623/liverpool002.jpg
http://img210.imageshack.us/img210/4470/liverpool006.jpg
http://img411.imageshack.us/img411/425/liverpool004.jpg

Thanks rob

[rcsmg1]

The autographs are Steve Macmanaman,Barry Venison, Gary Ablett, ? ,Steve McMahon,Glenn Hyssen,Ian Rush,Jan Molby,John Barnes,Dean Saunders,David Burrows nand Graeme Souness.
In saying that,I'm not 100% sure they're genuine as some of them don't look quite right.

[robboh2006]

yeah im not 100% sure but not familiar enough with them to make a decision, thanks for your opinion

[tots-junction-baby-shop]

If it belonged to someone's Grandad why would the autographs be not right?

[robboh2006]

some of them just dont look right on the eye just wondering wat other peoples thoughts were

[robboh2006]

some of them just dont look right on the eye just wondering wat other peoples thoughts were

[creefan04]

NO IDEA BUT I HOPE THEY GENUINE..

[tots-junction-baby-shop]

It just seems that when I've bought stuff for Jess from somebodies Grandads collection it seems they weren't so dishonest back then as folk are now 🙂

[thehornets]

I share #2's opinion - although they look close, something looks a little off, but it could have been due to rushed signing conditions. How did your friend's grandfather get them? In person at matches? At a book launch? Did he buy them? I can offer some of my sigs for comparison -

Ian Rush - http://www.cyshp.co.uk/irush.jpg

Ian Callagahn & Tommy Smith - http://www.cyshp.co.uk/lfc1.jpg

Steve McManaman - http://www.cyshp.co.uk/smcmanaman.jpg

John Barnes - http://www.cyshp.co.uk/jbarnes2.jpg

[robboh2006]

His grandad had them given as well so not sure where they came from....I have posted them on the new lfc forum and turns out they are no good they are fake which is a shame but nothing lost not gonna tell my mate n his grandad dont want them feeling bad n i deffo dont wanna seem ungrateful....plus side is there are some really good pictures in side that can be used for ttm.

Thanks everyone

[falcons_flyhalf]

#2 - rcsmg1 

The one you have the question mark against in the identification - could possibly be Garry Gillespie the Liverpool defender from the 80's, it looks simllar to his. 

[robboh2006]

maybe some hope for these sigs bob at retro reds has took a look at them and he thinks they are genuine just hope hes right....says he's gonna look into them so fingers crossed 🙂