06-03-2026 10:15 AM
OK, I sold an iMac and got paid, sent it out with the same packaging that I have used on several others and everything was fine.
The buyer contacts me a day after receiving the item saying it's damaged and they instigate a return, they send me pictures of the damage along with a description that clearly does not match the damage. In fact the corner of the iMac that was damaged would have been impossible to break in the way the pictures show it without destroying the whole machine. The buyer actually said in their description that the corners were well protected and the damage was on the side of the screen. The pictures are totally different the buyer is obviously lying.
I reported the buyer to eBay sating this is a bogus claim and that I wouldn't be refunding. Ebay didn't respond, now they have come back and said that they have sided with the buyer without any further investigation and they have awarded a full refund of £560 which they have taken from my bank account, I am also out of time to get the buyer to send the computer back. How is this fair????? Does eBay just side with the buyer everytime? If so then I can't use them any more as I sell high value items and the risk is too great.
I can't find a single way of getting in touch with them to challenge ay of this - it just seems completely arbitrary. Can anyone advise me what I should do next?
06-03-2026 10:22 AM
As a private seller, if you used simple delivery and buyer opens damaged in transit case, ebay refund them and you keep the money.
If they opened not as described case, you issue returns label & refund in full on return.
As you found, if you refuse or ignore not as described case, ebay make you refund & buyer keeps item.
If you want item back, you have to sort with buyer, ebay won't help.
06-03-2026 10:33 AM
Ok, thanks for that. So eBay don't care if the seller is demonstrably being dishonest? I did respond but didn't even get an acknowledgement, I raised a complaint against the buyer but never received any feedback on that.
Time to close my account and go for better platforms I think
06-03-2026 11:53 AM
We all agreed to this when signing up to ebay.
Ebay always believe buyers if they open case.
You can appeal after item is returned, but unfortunately few are granted.
06-03-2026 12:09 PM
OK Guess you will know a lot more about this than I do. I signed up to eBay in 2009 and so I don't really recall what the terms were back then. I assume that the terms telling me that I would be completely exposed to a sham buyer to the tune of nearly £600 without any recourse must have been in extremely small print. Now I know that the system is absolutely weighted in favour of the buyer I know better.