May i please have your comments and reasoning why Ebay take this action.

Seller lists an item 100% as described.   Buyer (who happens to be a dealer of said items by their own admission in messages)  open a not as described case.    Seller is left in an akward position.  Buyer is obviously a bad dealer if they do not realise what they are purchasing when its very clear in the listing.   They thought they were getting something worth several hundred for under £100s. 

After contacting Ebay CS they agree with the seller.....immediately close the case in the sellers favour BUT refund both seller and buyer and the buyer keeps all the expensive items.

The above is what i have an issue with.  Why should the buyer or seller get a refund/keep the proceeds of sale as well as the jewellery?????

Could Ebay not consider having said items returned to them directly somehow and forward them on to a charity or force the buyer to donate them to charity and only get refunded once they provide proof they have done this ????

A dishonest buyer could do the above a couple of times before Ebay realise what they are up to 😞 

Yes buyer has been blocked and reported.