a.i. descriptions are rubbish

So 'A.I' (so-called artificial intelligence) has found its way into ebay listings - but it's rubbish! It tells you nothing about the condition of an item, or its function - it just puts together a load of waffle based on the item specifics. Nothing 'intellegent' about it at all - just a quick fix for lazy sellers!

Message 1 of 121
See Most Recent
120 REPLIES 120

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Keep it simple it not hard

if selling new a description like this

  • Puffer Fish Enamel Pin Badge
  • Adorable cartoon design
  • 2.3 cm x 2.9 cm 
  • Peach & Beige 
  • Packed in a velvet gift bag

Tells you everything you need to now about the item

If selling used add in all the faults not rocket science really.

Yes AI descriptions are rubbish and I'm being polite.

Live long and prosper
Message 101 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Absolutely I am sick of messaging sellers to ask what fabric the article is made of or whether the pockets are real or false. I usually skip over the AI described items for sale now. Take note all you lazy sellers!

Message 102 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Checking the dates on most of these messages, we can see that AI generated descriptions have not improved over time plus looks like we are stuck with them. I've just returned to Ebay after sometime away and this AI description issue is making me question my return as both buyer and seller.

Message 103 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Microsoft co pilot is better it takes what you've written then changes it around ads in alternative words but never changes the context in any way.

Live long and prosper
Message 104 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

I was told by someone on here a few weeks ago that Ebay will push your items down the list of items for sale as they deem using Ai is lazy ,so why give sellers the opportunity to use it then . I like to know what size the item is ,what colour ,and any where or tear .I like to see plenty of photos too to show any wear etc .When I sell clothing I try to show the care labels inside too and close up photos too where possible . 

Message 105 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Agree, and the eBay AI is so ridiculously bad that it actually removes any valuable information a seller has just typed, only to replace it with meaningless AI generated waffle. 

Message 106 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Product manufacturers seem to be using AI increasingly, and many sellers feel they should include it because it's words by the manufacturer and, worse, totally replace the seller's own more useful words such as the condition of a 'used' item, size/dimensions, or, in the category I mainly shop in, "needs an A4 die cutting machine" (not everyone has one), "ideal for making [certain format] cards", "comes with artwork - download it free from the manufacturer's website".

 

Perhaps such sellers feel whatever a manufacturer writes, no matter how inane or uninformative, is more important than what they would write? so that, apart from that, the listing's Description is empty (apart from, say, "comes from a smoke-free home" or "I combine postage").

Message 107 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Is there anyway we can get eBay to abandon AI description? There has been items I'm interested in but put off because the seller has used AI which robs the description of the important facts which anyone would require to know. It's just a useless toy or worse, a means of unscrupulous sellers hiding defects.

Message 108 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

a means of unscrupulous sellers hiding defects.

 

Private sellers apparently can do this ( hide defects) BUT they cannot misrepresent any items under law. Further A.I. is being used as a " convenience" and promoted as such, when it could not be further from the truth. It is artificial and not intelligent other than " picking up" what "other" descriptions have stated and being far too generic often withholding vital  information for buyers to determine. It is the sellers responsibility to ensure any written listing descriptions depict what they are selling accurately. By not doing so, and using " generic" A.I. descriptors this could result in a multitude of claims for not as described.  

I agree A.I is superfluous

Message 109 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Join the queue. Being trying to get eBay to listen for the last two years, but falling on deaf ears.

Sent from my iPhone X
Message 110 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

I agree, marketing waffle and I've had 2 items lately which have gone straight in the bin, 20 plus years with eBay, time for a change, lots of poor quality garments getting through,  not genuine pre loved clothes,  probably why they introduced mandatory buyer protection,  think ebay have lost the plot

Message 111 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Well on the other side, I’m listing an item for sale and it’s rejected as trying to sell outside of eBay.

Ai sees a battery number in one of my photos as a telephone number, so rejects the listing. Suggestion from eBay? Remove the photo!

You couldn’t make it up!

Message 112 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Agree they are terrible, not only do they tell you nothing about the item, aside from the fact that you are missing out by not owning it, they just blurt out a load of Innacurate rubbish. I've stopped bothering with things with Ai listings now. 
If people can't be bothered to tell you about the item I can't be bothered to message them and ask for an actual description. 


it's particularly bad for Vinyl records 

eBay should remove this option for descriptions in my opinion 

Message 113 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

I have a degree in IT, specialising in AI, NI and cybernetics, but would never use it to write my ads, simply because I am a human writing TO humans and have a personal desire to ensure 100% accuracy and relevance.

 

A computer generated advert will never say what I personally wish to convey, but remember that AI needs to 'learn' so the more it is used, the better it becomes  and if some sellers are happy to rely upon it, then good luck to them

Message 114 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Remove at least a couple of stars in the review for the innaccurate description.

Message 115 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

I totally agree with your comments about AI.  It doesn't describe the particular item for sale at all and they just read as cheesy promotions of whatever. It's very lazy and can't be trusted. 

Yesterday I looked at the basics of getting started on eBay and the information needs updating. It refers to 12 photos being added to the listing and stresses the importance of accurate and honest descriptions of the items being sold. This is the opposite of what AI does and it's a good example of how eBay has lowered its standards. Don't get me started on the buyer protection racket and simple delivery  - a totally false description if there ever was one.

Message 116 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Helps me,i struggle with describing,im dyslexic...

Message 117 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

Hi, yes I do fully appreciate how helpful AI is to people with certain
problems. I did say previously that I could see how it may be useful to
people where English is their second language. Since
I first made this post a couple of years ago the use of AI has reached
epidemic proportions. Even old stagers like myself are taking the lazy way
out. I've recently bought a couple of items from well established private
eBayers with 100% FB who used AI descriptions. This entailed me in having
to waste time asking questions which would have been included in any
manually written description.
I will always stick to writing my own descriptions as I feel that it
gets me one step ahead of sellers using AI. I now feel
like King Canute trying to hold back the tide!
Message 118 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

I totally agree and like you, will always write my own descriptions. AI can only give a generic description of the item for sale, it knows nothing of your particular item's condition etc.
It just gives a flowery description of how great the manufacturer is, what great materials its made of and how something like a sink plunger will enhance your home. Had I known, I would have put mine on the mantlepiece for all to admire!

Cheers,

Pete
Message 119 of 121
See Most Recent

a.i. descriptions are rubbish

I've just messaged a seller because the broken faulty playstation 5 controller they have listed says it has a 12 month warranty!

eBay item number:146781766108
Message 120 of 121
See Most Recent
Got selling tools related questions? Start here: