11-03-2025 9:20 AM
If I had had one single item go missing, if I had had one single item get damaged in the post, I would not have a problem paying this ridiculous scam money that goes only to eBay, for a couple of months and providing there were no further infractions, go back to normal.
The fact I have to pay this ( we’re all lowering the price of our items so the buyer doesn’t have to pay it, right? It’s the only GD way anyone will even look at your listings) despite having no missing or damaged items, and in fact extremely happy buyers without exception, is offensive to me. eBay is saying “we don’t trust you”,
despite an impeccable record, and that is disgraceful. I don’t care if it’s the law, eBay
should pay it until a seller gives them a reason not to.
The handling of this absolute debacle, and forcing me to declare my HOBBY as an additional revenue, (when we all know that what we make in sales we only reinvest in order to keep going. I’m not profiting off my cards - and now I’m lucky to get ONE VIEW A DAY on my listings, even though they’ve been undercut by others so many times that they are barely worth half of what they were two weeks ago) is pathetic. Why there is no in between, I don’t know. Even if I didn’t reinvest on other cards and used the money from sales to try and keep bills paid and myself warm and fed, I would’ve been homeless after a month and starving after two.
I don’t blame others for undercutting, although it is annoying and selfish, but this is some people’s livelihood, and due to the sheer ineptitude in the way it’s been handled, people are get desperate.
Imagine ruining a huge chunk of your user base’s ability to enjoy their hobby as a hobby, then alienating another huge chunk with the way you handle fees, then destroying all credibility and reputation of your multi billion dollar company with a faulty product, removing the ability to make any money at all from 90% of your user base, and removing the ability FOR YOUR OWN COMPANY to make any profits.
It is an unprecedented failure on so many levels it’s hard to believe. It might be the single biggest implosion of a successful mega corporation ever.
I can’t see it getting fixed and I don’t want to think how long it will take to gain back their reputation and trust - it will take an immediate and significant change in the way they treat buyers and sellers, and even then it probably won’t work.
Jesus Christ, eBay, you have messed up historically. If it’s any consolation at all, whoever is calling the shots will be remembered for a long time for their sheer ineptitude and shortsightedness.
11-03-2025 10:54 AM
I don’t care if it’s the law
The handling of this absolute debacle, and forcing me to declare my HOBBY as an additional revenue,
If something is the law, then you can hardly blame Ebay for it. Frankly though, I have no idea what you are actually talking about with that statement.
However, Ebay are NOT forcing you to declare your hobby income. HMRC are forcing Ebay to do so.
And in any case, the law in regarding to declaring your income has not changed. You should have been doing so anyway, which from the tone of your post it is quite clear that you have not done so in the past.
So who is wrong?
I would suggest that you go away and think about it. Understand what you are talking about and then comment on it. Go look at the legislation, that clears it all up.
11-03-2025 11:28 AM
Because you're in the same category as me, you may want to check you're getting charged 10p and not 30p final value fixed fees. Mine's been broken for weeks, and the more pressure on support to fix the better:
https://community.ebay.co.uk/t5/Business-Seller-Board/quot-10p-Per-Order-Fees-For-Sales-up-to-10-in-...
11-03-2025 12:34 PM
They are a private seller!
11-03-2025 6:48 PM
Neither eBay nor HMRC are forcing ANYONE to declare hobby income.
HMRC are not even requesting that anyone declare hobby income, except in the case of individual items that are sold for £3000 or £6000, depending upon the circumstances.
Can you please direct me to any legislation that states that hobby income will have to be declared.
11-03-2025 7:11 PM
I suggest that you read that again.
The current legislation that has been introduced, is making ebay report ALL income received on Ebay to HMRC.
It doesn't matter whether that be hobby/business whatever.
12-03-2025 3:18 PM
Ok, I've read it again - and again I ask - what current legislation are you referring too?
It wouldn't be the European wide digital platform reporting perchance, because that is certainly not 'making ebay report ALL income received on Ebay to HMRC'. It does require eBay to report sales over £1700 pa, or over a certain number of items sold.
And, for the OP, that legislation doesn't force him to declare his hobby as additional revenue. It merely provides HMRC with information which MAY lead HMRC to enquire about his online sales.
Though, of course, they are always tax advantages to declaring a hobby as a business, worth having a chat with an accountant for a couple of hours - he would be able to give information on business allowances and also on the viability of a hobby becoming a business - in many cases it wouldn't be viewed by HMRC as a business. A hobby is generally an investment, pieces sold in order to buy better or more pieces, sold to realise the investment,or held simply for enjoyment. Investments can go up and down, businesses have to have the intent to make a profit and an income. Two completely different things, one subject to CGT where the investment realised is more than the original purchase price, the other to Income Tax or Corporation Tax on nett profits.