Seller claims Evri stole item - case closed in Seller favour
Summary: fatlog_senpai describes a challenging situation with an item they sold online for £100, which went missing and was replaced by a different item in transit. Despite assurances from eBay advisors that they would be covered, the case was closed in favor of the buyer, resulting in a loss for fatlog_senpai. They have escalated the issue and are awaiting a supervisor's callback, expressing frustration over the lack of protection despite eBay's policies.
Long story - so will try and be brief...
I sold an item two weeks ago for £100 so not insignificant. Postage through simple delivery to an Evri Parcel Shop.
It went missing with Evri for about a week. Tracking saying label problems etc.
Buyer opened item not received case.
It then showed up on Monday. Buyer claims it was opened and some random bottle of hair product was in it. In fairness, it does look like one end was opened up & resealed with different tape to what I used...
I spoke to an Ebay advisor on Monday, they said accept the return when it arrives call us back. I specifically asked if I will be covered as the item isnt coming back to me - they said yes.
Return case opened
I spoke to an Agent 3 days later as the tracking on the return hadnt updated at all, despite being 48hr tracked. So the case was put on hold for 9(!?) Days to allow it to arrive
Random bottle of hair product arrives back at my house on Friday - spoke to my third advisor, who sent me a document to fill in, sign and send back. To get my money back via ebay money back guarantee. Okay, I have to print the doc etc so the case will be put on hold for 5 days.
Between Friday morning and 6pm the case has been closed in the buyers favour - despite the above, and money being recovered from me. So £100 and the item down.
Spoke to advisor number 4 Friday evening - who basically said, the case is closed nothing Ebay can do now. And that I have to speak to Evri to try and get my money. I have escalated, and am waiting for a supervisor call back...
Anybody been in this spot or similar?! I feel like it pretty clearly says in the terms of simple delivery that youre covered for this type of thing? And all the info I can find related to this, says Evri cannot refund me as the shipping contract is with Ebay...
papso22
Simple delivery provides seller protection if an item doesn't arrive or if the buyer opens a returns case using the very specific reason of 'arrived damaged'.
There is no seller protection if a buyer opens a case using any other reason.
If buyer sends back something different to what you sent, there are things a seller can do but that is not 'getting your money back under the money back guarantee ' as the MBG protects buyers not sellers. The steps include making a report to report fraud and then using the report a buyer process to freeze the refund. It doesn't sound like you did this.
You are right, you cannot deal with Evri as you have no contract with them.
It seems that you have been seriously misled by ebay CS. This is not uncommon and unfortunately ebay will take no responsibility for it.