Return case raised with photos of a completely different item
Summary: robinson_flyer experienced a return case issue where a buyer claimed their item was "broken" using unrelated photos, and provided no further communication. They contacted eBay, which agreed the photos were irrelevant but still refunded the buyer at no cost to robinson_flyer. robinson_flyer expressed confusion and concern that the buyer might be incentivized by such actions. *vyolla* reassured that the buyer will likely be flagged by eBay, noting it was fortunate robinson_flyer incurred no loss.
Just had a return case raised against me where the buyer just said one word "broken" in the description and provided three not-very clear photos of some old hand tools - nothing whatsoever to do with the item I sold to him. He went uncommunicative when this was raised with him through the return case - and I had no option to decline the return case, so I had to mess about getting in contact with ebay this morning to raise the issue with them.
Ebay could see his photos and agreed they were nothing to do with my item - so I expected they would simply cancel the return case and ask the buyer to raise it again either with the correct photos if there was a genuine issue with my item such as it being damaged in post, OR against the correct order if he raised it against my order by mistake. Instead, ebay just refunded him (at no expense to me so at least I'm not out of pocket). I can't pretend I understand the logic of this because the buyer has now been REWARDED for clearly and demonstrably making a mistake and not even explaining himself let alone doing anything about it.
I can only assume ebay take the view that with it being a low value item, it just isn't worth their time trying to sort the buyer out - but it sends the wrong message out IMHO.
Or is this some sort of scam?
department28
'I can't pretend I understand the logic of this because the buyer has now been REWARDED for clearly and demonstrably making a mistake and not even explaining himself let alone doing anything about it.'
Yes, it does seem like eBay do more 'auto-refunding' these days, so some people are getting a refund that they don't necessarily 'deserve'.
I had a buyer return a pair of shoes that were unused, but quite old. The shoe box was a bit fragile, so I posted them in an outer box, with bubble wrap & packing paper. The day after they arrived, the buyer wanted to return as 'didn't fit'. No problem, but they returned them sloppily packed in a taped-up bin bag - no outer box or any of my packaging. Inevitably, they arrived back with damage to the box.
Having added photos of the damage, eBay just refunded the buyer - even though it was entirely their fault that the item was damaged in the post. Obviously, I was glad not to have to cover the refund, but imo, the buyer did not merit a full refund from eBay.
*vyolla*
That buyer will be on eBay's red flag list now, they'll only get the benefit of the doubt once and at least you didn't lose out.