Need some advice please
Summary: boomcard shared an experience on a marketplace platform, where they refunded a buyer for a bracelet before receiving the item back, only for the buyer to later claim the bracelet was discarded. cobwebcottage explained that issuing a refund before a return classifies it as voluntary, which was why the buyer kept the bracelet. Participants advised boomcard to block the buyer, monitor their sales for possible resale of the bracelet, and highlighted this scenario as a learning opportunity. Others discussed the broader issue of sellers refunding prematurely and suggested that platforms provide clearer guidance to prevent these situations.
Hello, I am getting no help from Ebay, so I'm on here to ask advice. I sold a Jackie Brazil bracelet for £20 and then the lady said it was unwearable and wanted a refund. I didn't understand as I bought it new and had been sitting in my draw ever since. It was worn just twice (once to try when I bought and once to take a photo of it on my wrist to sell. I gave her a refund and asked her to return. She had the refund and stopped replying to my messages. I kept asking her to return the bracelet so I could resell. She has just got back to say she has disguarded the braclet! I am getting no reply from Ebay.
Any suggestions?
Thank you in advance
Rachel
This is the braclette the lady said was totally unusable/unwearable

boomcard
OPThank you everyone for your help. You gave all been so useful and I have learnt a lot! 👍
del_girl_delights
Never ever refund before receiving a returned item !!!!! Massive learning curve for you
*vyolla*
With respect to all you folks who are refunding before getting your item back and then expecting the buyer to return it, I don't understand why you're doing this? You can't contact M&S and let them know that you want to return a dressing gown that is damaged and expect an instant refund, you have to return the item to M&S and then you get your refund.
There is no selling platform, either online or bricks and mortar, that expects a seller to refund before first getting their item back.
department28
Yes, this definitely seems to be an 'only on eBay' thing! I think some sellers can feel a bit pressured into responding quickly to a disgruntled buyer, and agree to refund straight away - only realising what they have done when it's too late... In particular, an inexperienced seller could easily feel panicked into doing this.
As a buyer, I would not be happy - or feel entitled - to keep an item if the seller was expecting it to be returned, even if it was their error for refunding too soon.
jonatjonatjonat
Amazon in some instances do refund but state they will recharge you if you don’t return it within X days. But that is an exception not the rule.
I’ve never understood it either. I don’t think it’s something eBay should need to point out either. I’ve seen complaints on here when ebay tell you how to package and send an order. So do people want ebay to hold their hand, or not?
department28
Well, I guess any seller who does this once, probably doesn't do it a second time...
boomcard
OPYes. As I’ve never had to give a refund I didn’t know this was a thing. I do now though. Learnt the hard way!
department28
As you have spotted, another seller has posted today about this same situation - refunding before the buyer has opened a returns case.
Perhaps eBay could add a pop-up box before a seller attempts to issue a refund, as a reminder not to refund before the item has been returned, if you definitely want the item back. It would save a lot of sellers from making this hasty mistake.
Did the buyer give a reason why they thought the bracelet was 'unwearable'?! Keep an eye on their listings... you might find they try to resell it at some point...
boomcard
OPI agree. I didn’t know about this as I’m too trusting. It was on for £30 (basic price for this designer item). First she got it down to £20 then told it was unwearable and was all stretched as it had been worn too much. I only wore it to try on then later when I took a photo of it on. Apart from that it had sat in a drawer. She claimed I was not selling the truth about the item I sold. I couldn’t be bothered to argue. Gave her the refund and asked her to post it back (as I knew I could sell for more anyway). She ghosted me. Then told me she had discarded it. From now on I won’t be so trusting of people.
But yes! EBay should help people with this.
theelench
No-one has said "Put the buyer on your Blocked List". To stop them getting any more freebies from you.
cobwebcottage
Buyers have to open a returns case and you wait for the return of the item AND THEN refund them.
Because you refunded them first, it is classed as a voluntary refund and there is nothing you can do if the buyer is refusing to return it.
boomcard
OPThank you so much, that’s really helpful. So it’s my mistake.
Shame that EBay couldn’t have explained this to me.
Cheers though 😁
cobwebcottage
No problem. It sounds like your buyer knows the system well and now has a lovely bracelet for free.
boomcard
OPDo I give feedback on this person? Or is it not
wise to be honest?
jonatjonatjonat
As a seller you can only leave Positive feedback for buyers. If you leave a false positive with negative comments - this can be removed.
especially as they haven't actually done anything wrong - this was your mistake unfortunately.
boomcard
OPAmazing. Thank you for your help. Lesson learnt.
cobwebcottage
You can block them. The odds of them buying another item from you are slim but it may make you feel better!
Go to help and contact at the top of the page and search for block buyer and add their username.
boomcard
OPI’ve just looked them up. They are also selling on here too!!
apricotwhirl
Just curious, are they selling your bracelet? If so, that would be theft and you could try sending an LBA
boundarycoins
As they are selling it @boomcard I would check the description and if they make no mention of the flaw they claimed I would ring eBay and ask them to have a look at the case. No guarantees at all but you may find that they could give a discretionary refund to you if you can show they abused the moneyback guarantee.
It may be a waste of time but I’d try. It not, as you’ve already said it’s a lesson learned and in the long run may be £30 well spent if you ever have to deal with this type of issue again with a more expensive item.