Defective item
Summary: rodders501 shared an experience about selling three vintage railway wagons on eBay, where one wagon was defective. Despite providing photos and noting the defect, the buyer initiated a return, which was automatically accepted by eBay. rodders501 received various suggestions from other participants, including separating defective items when listing, using clear language in descriptions, and understanding that the eBay Buyer Protection system may still result in returns. In the end, the buyer closed the case, leaving rodders501 feeling that more careful listings could prevent similar issues in the future. The conversation highlighted challenges with eBay's return system and the expectations of vintage item buyers.
Hi, can anyone please give me their thoughts on this situation.
I sold 3 vintage railway Hornby wagons as a single lot, one was defective (broken coupling), the other 2 were fine.
I know I should have written more in the details, but I did state 'note the coupling' and clearly took photo's to show this defect.
Also I should have mentioned this particular wagon was being given away free, only the 2 remaining wagons had good value and were sold below the average price for a single wagon let alone 2.
Ebay automatically accepted a return, I have done nothing, no complaint or dispute this, not worth the hassle it creates.
I did message the buyer asking why they decided to return these wagons as I clearly shown photo's of the defective wagon, but received no reply.
Am I to assume that even if any item, not just my items, are in less than perfect condition, even if you state as such in your listing, buyers can return with no redress?
johniow
Just looked at your listing, the problem is you're selling Hornby Dublo. Your buyers are likely to be the older generation and they tend to be a bit more demanding, as I know to my cost. Whenever I sell HD or the early Triang stuff I do tend to give a lot more detail than I would for the newer stuff. Unfortunately you are caught in the Buyer Protection system and the buyer can still leave negative feedback even if you refund in full. Take care out there.
rodders501
OPIt is difficult and as you state, it tends to appeal more to those that are very experienced in these solid metal and tin constructed items.
I know I should have been much more explicit in my listing and as mentioned prior, I could have offered the damaged wagon for free, I did not think of that so I am very grateful for the advice given here.
I do still feel even if i had done this, it still would have left me open to a return, such is the eBay buyer protection system.
Many of these collectors of 1950's and 1960's Hornby Dublo items are very adept at repairing these items, I would rather someone have the 'less than perfect' items so they have the option of repairing or using for spare parts themselves rather than bin them, but as I have written, I do still feel it leaves me open to a return though
gjalp
Always use the words defective/defect/faulty for any part of an item that is as such. You will at least be able to contact ebay and state the return due to faulty was incorrect as it was stated in the listing. I would also sell the faulty one separately away from others. Some people like to repair things plus they will then be clear on what they are buying.
rodders501
OPThank you, I have many wagons and coaches that are in damaged condition, I was intending to list them as one job lot, all with as you written.
Keeping the faulty one away from good used items is a very good idea, one I will do in the future
eastern_standard_time
"one was defective (broken coupling), the other 2 were fine. I know I should have written more in the details, but I did state 'note the coupling' and clearly took photo's to show this defect."
I'm not sure how much more you could have done than mentioning it in the description and including photos of it. But it's all irrelevant anyway, as buyers get to do whatever they want. Unfortunately dealing with people like this is the price we pay for selling on this platform.
rodders501
OPCobwebcottage gave me a lovely answer and I fully agree with what was written.
I could have done my listing much better, but of the 3 wagons I did ensure to include clear photo's of the damaged item, this means nothing to eBay.
I have heard many times that if a buyer is unhappy for any reason whatsoever, all they have to do is open a case and eBay will request a return on their behalf.
It is a small price, nothing to get angry about, but it does make you wonder if it's worth all the hassle at times.
I will follow Cobwebcottage's advice in the future, it seems more appropriate and hopefully will be more satisfying to my customers
missdollydaydream
Do NOT refund untill you have the items back.
rodders501
OPI have no intention of refunding prior, there is a button I can press to offer a refund and they also get to keep the items, to hell with that, they can send it back and I will relist with corrections of course, and I will block him from future purchases too.
I love eBay, normally happy to buy and sell here, just some things are not perfect, but it is what it is, live and learn
cobwebcottage
By your own admission, it sounds like you did not fully describe the items and any faults thoroughly.
You could have listed the two wagons and then enclosed the one for free as a bonus rather than include it in the listing.
If a buyer is not happy with the items and feel that they were misdescribed and not what they expected then they have a right to return them for a full refund.
rodders501
OPAdmittedly I made mistakes and thank you for your reply, greatly appreciated
cobwebcottage
We all live and learn by our mistakes.
gjalp
I wouldnt do this particularly if its a collectible otherwise the buyer may think you are trying to offload your ‘rubbish’ on them and take great offense.
rodders501
OPThese are collectable items, many repair the 'less than perfect' items and take great pleasure in doing so, no original Hornby Dublo items are ever considered as rubbish.
The price I set on all three wagons, which obviously included the damaged one, was around the same price as other listings for just one wagon at the time of listing.
I felt this was a giveaway bargain, the other two wagons are great, obviously not so in someone's eyes, but you live and learn
gjalp
Problem is, how you view things may not be the same as others. The things I collect, I would be a little disgruntled to have a faulty item in when buying. I personally disregard broken items and while I may buy less than perfect, when I do it is targeted. When there is a group of items, unless a fault is shouting at me from the listing, I either don't see it or my focus is on the item I am wanting to buy.
However, in this instance, my method would be to message the seller to say I didnt want it/didnt realise it was broken and what would be the best way to resolve the problem.
rodders501
OPI felt at the time and clearly showing photo's of all 3 wagons, all be it one broken, I was doing what I had to do in being honest. Each one of these wagons tend to sell for around £7 each, I had 2 that were good condition for just the same price. I do have many of these wagons and coaches that do have pieces missing, but they are always great for those with the skills to repair or use as spare parts. Obviously if this is likely to cause me issues again, I would rather scrap them at my recycling centre, but what a waste of items that are not common to find these days
eastern_standard_time
It was clearly described as damaged in the listing. If you can't be bothered to read the listing properly, as your post suggests, then that's down to you.
gjalp
I personally can't see any descriptions to read recently. They come up as a flash and then Im dropped to feedback. Despite reporting this numerous times, I am yet to see a fix. If I'm having this issue, you can bet your life others are! Im now not buying on ebay simply because I can't see the descriptions.
rodders501
OPSadly not a view shared by eBay. If I saw a listing similar to what I did, and I wanted the items for my collection, I would not hesitate to bid and used the damaged item for spares. No complaints, nothing, a bargain price, but some buyers are one sheet short of a toilet roll these days. Incidentally the buyer has still not returned the items, eBay automatically approved a return, so I assume they supply a label and charge me, but it still sits at 'awaiting buyer to post' stage
rodders501
OPUpdate, as of today 02 November. Buyer has closed the case and the funds are in my account, no explanation, nothing. Pleased with the outcome but do understand I need to be more careful with damaged items, even if they are very collectable