Why is my eBay payment held for missing parcel?
Summary: podlingsmum shared their issue with an eBay transaction where a parcel sent using simple delivery hasn't updated for ten days, resulting in their funds being held. The parcel tracking showed it reached a specific point but didn't progress further. Despite contacting eBay and having tracking information, podlingsmum was found at fault for not supplying tracking details, which was supposed to be automatically updated by eBay. Other participants, including sml192 and all4fate, shared similar experiences, highlighting eBay's tendency to refund buyers when cases are opened without fully investigating the tracking status. marco@ebay from eBay offered to look into the issue, and retroman303 provided advice on handling such discrepancies. Eventually, podlingsmum decided not to proactively contact buyers about such issues in the future.
I recently sold an item and used the simple delivery label. Unfortunately the tracking hasn't updated for ten days so it seems to be lost. I advised my buyer to open an item not received case. Why are my funds for the item now on hold? I thought as it was simple delivery, I'm not responsible for it going missing? Is this just procedure by ebay?
The outcome today is that ebay are intending to deduct the refund from my account. The case states that I did not supply tracking. The order page clearly shows the label was supplied to me.
When looking to appeal this decision, it states to go to seller dashboard and it will show the case without seller resolution. This does not show as only seller performance from 1st Nov 2025 to 31st Oct 2026 is there.
I had to get a call back from ebay. The agent said I will be contacted in the next 48-72 hours. I am concerned how this has happened. How the agent closed the case with the outcome that it was my fault.
podlingsmum
OPMy appeal was granted and I am due to receive a refund. But this should not have happened in the first place. Thank you to everyone who commented.
boundarycoins
Hate to say it but that parcel likely got delivered with no scan.
If I’m misunderstanding some posts here please correct me but did you tell the buyer to open an INR case without prompting? It doesn’t change what sounds like a strange eBay decision but just putting it out there that it is best to not open a can of worms unless the tracking is definitely pointing to a lost parcel.
podlingsmum
OPThe simple delivery tracking showed it hadn't moved for ten days. I did message the buyer but why should that mean I'm liable?
boundarycoins
It shouldn’t. As other people read the forum and many won’t comment I’m just saying in the same situation just leave the buyer to report it if they didn’t receive the item rather than point out a freebie can be had.
It does sound like they were going to do nothing but opened a case after being told the tracking hadn’t updated. I know it’s a cynical way of looking at it but that’s what I assumed and has now been as good as confirmed.
eBay’s handling of this situation is still very confusing though.
podlingsmum
OPIt was a tracked 48 label, a small parcel, and it's supposed to be scanned at delivery.
boundarycoins
For whatever reason it wasn’t scanned, I see it happen on mine more often than I would like.
I did look at the tracking before jumping to conclusions, it made it to the buyers local delivery office and was scanned onto a round so we can safely say it went out for delivery. To me, with no buyer contact to report an issue for 10 days afterwards, 9 times out of 10 this was probably a successful delivery with no scan. If it had not moved at all in the network from the time you posted it then that’s different maybe it would justify reaching out to the buyer.
If you’re eBay offering simple delivery protection would you encourage sellers to tell buyers every time an item didn’t get scanned delivered? I have a vested interest in suggesting to private sellers please don’t because it costs eBay / RM in refunded fees / loss claims and as an eBay fee payer the more they lose on these it could end up putting my fees up.
That’s pretty much all I have to say on it. I can tell you acted in good faith with the buyer so I’m not digging you out especially but more so with this type of simple delivery scenario.
podlingsmum
OPI won't message any buyers in future. I take on board your point.
marco@ebay
Hi @podlingsmum , thanks for your post.
Do you have the item number for the transaction, so I can take a look for you? The funds should be placed on hold while there is an open case as per our money back guarantee policy, so that's normal. However, if there are no records of delivery (lost in transit), and it was sent with Simple Delivery, you should be covered. If it wasn't sent with Simple Delivery and the case was no actioned, then that'd be why you see the case closed without seller's resolution, but once you confirm the item number, I'll be happy to take a look.
Thank you,
Marco
podlingsmum
OP237086070430
marco@ebay
Thanks for confirming, @podlingsmum .
I've just sent this for review now, and the team should get back to me within 48 hours, once I find out more about this, I will let you know over here.
Thank you,
Marco
marco@ebay
Hi @podlingsmum , thanks for your patience around this.
The team has confirmed to me that you've put an appeal through our customer service team, so there is no need for them to review the case. When this happens, your appeal decision will be final and the outcome should be seen in your eBay account and emails. If you check there, you should be able to see the outcome of your appeal.
Thank you,
Marco
podlingsmum
OPVU796873046GB is the simple delivery tracking.
retroman303
This really doesn't sound right at all.
With Simple Delivery, a tracking number would have automatically been created, so - as you say - why would you even need to provide one? eBay already has it (or should do).
Also, under the terms of SD you should be protected from an INR claim (more specifically , you should not have to refund). That's one of the heavily-promoted benefits of SD.
I know you're waiting for a callback, but let's be honest, loads of members have been promised that, only for the call to never come. So, given that something here definitely seems to have gone skew-whiff, I hope you don't mind me tagging the Community Managers.
@kat@ebay @dave@ebay @marco@ebay Hi, could one of you please shed some light on this and help the OP out? Thank you.
podlingsmum
OPI did get a callback. They will email me in 48-72 hours. I also had a chat conversation about it so I could get a transcript afterwards. There hasn't been an apology or an agreement that this was their error.
retroman303
Well, just getting a callback (and within the stated time) is quite a result!
I hope you get this sorted, the T&Cs are definitely on your side (or should be). And Marco should be able to help now you've provided those numbers. Please report back with how you got on.
It's probably best to try not to be hopeful for an apology and/or an admission of error from eBay, that way you won't be disappointed at not getting one.
podlingsmum
OPThank you. Is it significant that the registered address, post to address, and the order details address are different. All Warrington postcodes?
retroman303
@podlingsmum
Hi there, not sure if you're aware, but your comment above (about three different Warrington postcodes) was sent as a reply to me, whereas I suspect it was intended as a reply to Marco, who has said he'll get back to you.
That's not a complaint at all. If anything warrants complaint, it's the confusing structure of these forums. In fact, I only know that you replied to my comment because I got an email informing me - otherwise, I'd have been none the wiser, even if I'd seen your comment first!
(This is why, when I remember to, I tag the person I'm replying to,. That way, at least people know whom I'm addressing, even if it's still not necessarily obvious which of that person's posts I'm responding to.)
Wishing you a successful resolution. By the looks of things, you shouldn't be in this predicament.
all4fate
I am unsure of official eBay policy, but from experience this is what happens.
Ebay put funds of hold while they 'review' the case. However the 'review' (again in my experience only) seems to be they look at what the tracking says and if it isn't confirmed delivered, they refund the buyer, give seller a defect for unresolved case and take your funds.
All seems pretty unfair when you have no input in the process at all...how did the seller not resolve the case??
I was under the mistaken idea they would look into the situation properly, ascertain where the parcel was and help the buyer to receive their goods - this is not my experience sadly.
podlingsmum
OPI am the seller, and used the simple delivery label supplied. If the postage had been my responsibility I definitely would have refunded the buyer and would have been able to claim for the loss from Royal Mail. When the item appeared to be lost in transit I messaged the buyer. I received the message about the buyer reaching out and that ebay would deal with issues about delivery. I sent two messages to the buyer, the second message I advised the buyer to open a case for item not received. As it was simple delivery I did not expect the case outcome.
all4fate
Exactly my experience too.
Have had a couple of these - parcel delayed, buyer opens case.
If tracking doesn't confirm delivered Ebay refund the buyer (within hours of case opening) without helping to locate/shift the parcel in the system and get the order to them, or asking them to wait just a little longer or anything.
I don't know what the communication to the buyer is like from eBay, probably pretty cut and paste I'm guessing.
All in all, I would rather handle the situation myself if all eBay is going to do is look at the tracking and automatically refund....take your money and give you a defect (when you're not even involved in the process of trying to resolve).
I might add as well that both parcels turned up within a few days of the buyer being refunded - and eBay has no simple mechanism for seller to get repaid for the order.
As you are finding, it doesn't work in the seller's favour at all.
Let us know if you get any joy from eBay.
sml192
Does the tracking show that it was received by the parcel shop? Are there any other scans after that to show that it was received by the carrier?
podlingsmum
OPYes I have a receipt and the item reached Warrington and did not progress after 21st Oct.
sml192
In that case you should definitely be covered under the terms for Simple Delivery.
podlingsmum
OPYes, you would think so but an agent decided the case against me as I did not supply tracking. I didn't need to add the tracking as it's already updated by ebay as it's their label.
podlingsmum
OPHas nobody wanted to comment?