Presale scam / buyer money back guarantee / presale policy
Hi all,
I’d be grateful for some assistance. I purchased a presale item on 21 January 2026 and was advised of a dispatch date of 20 February 2026 (which is in line with eBay’s 40 day presale policy: https://www.ebay.co.uk/help/policies/listing-policies/presale-listings-policy?id=4252).
On 23 January 2026 the seller sent an invoice further confirming the dispatch date of 20th Feb 2026. This is what showed up as ‘delivered’ on eBay’s page (but I have proof in the form of the invoice I received and the Royal Mail proof of postage/photo that it wasn’t the item).
I didn’t raise any issue initially because it was still within the relevant period, however a few days after 20th of Feb, I looked at the seller’s page and noticed various negative feedback indicating a scam and the seller’s own page noted they’d had their account suspended by eBay.
I messaged the seller on 23 Feb asking what was happening and noted I’d seen the restriction on their account. I got no reply and so launched a ‘not received’ request through customer services who assured me that I was covered and would receive a refund but they also asked that I make sure I raise a request within 30 days in the future (which I noted, but advised I didn’t think I could because the item was not due for dispatch until 20th Feb and would need to allow a few days for delivery). I went away feeling pretty positive that I was protected.
To my surprise, eBay then randomly closed the case claiming it was outside the 30 day guarantee and despite me emailing to appeal and making the position clear, they plainly didn’t properly consider and promptly closed the appeal too.
The item was within the eBay money back guarantee as (i) the item was never delivered AND my dispute was raised within 30 days from the due dispatch date. Additionally it was raised within the 40 day presale guarantee period.
So disappointed to be let down by eBay here as a long-term customer (and seller). It feels like such a cop out - it’s not out of the money back guarantee and if what they’re saying is right, the 40 day presale policy is entirely ineffective because you lose your rights at 30 days.
I spoke with someone helpful at customer service after who gave me some hope and indicated they were going to try and get me a discretionary refund and reassured me, but a few days have passed now and not heard anything further. Any advice/ideas?
papso22
MentorThe seller sent the 'invoice' knowing you would then lose an item not received claim. As far as ebay are concerned that was the early delivery of what you ordered. The seller was clearly a scammer.
You needed to open an item not as described case.
The problem is that receipt of that document started the 30 day window to open an item not as described case, and you are now beyond that.
Had they not sent anything you would have had 30 days from the expected delivery date to make a claim.
If you can't make a claim through your funding source, your only hope is a concessionary refund from ebay.
tobhay-82
OPThank you. I kick myself now because it was so obvious in hindsight. I know in the past eBay were much more forgiving and sympathetic with buyers and would take evidence into account - is the Royal Mail P.O.P showing the letter worth nothing as it clearly isn’t the large box/heavy product I bought? So frustrating.
The guarantee specifically says:
“When you shop on eBay.co.uk and pay at eBay checkout, your purchase is covered by eBay Money Back Guarantee for 30 days from the estimated or actual delivery date”.
It was plainly within the estimated delivery date period and I have the photographic proof of postage from RM (and the invoice itself which is from a third party merely stating due for dispatch 20th Feb) which evidences that there was no ‘actual delivery’. The first message from the seller was also clear:
“Delivery has been arranged to ship directly to you once the product releases, and confirmation will be sent out.
Please rest assured that you’re fully protected for up to 40 days under eBay’s presale policy.
***This message also serves as a record for both of us in eBay messages, confirming that this is a presale order and that the item is scheduled to be dispatched on 20th February 2026***”
Like you say though - eBay don’t seem to care - wouldn’t touch a presale in the future with a barge pole!
Guess I just have to hope to hear back on the discretionary front!
john1297576
MentorEbay just probably automatically accept tracked proof of delivery as being for the item purchased.
As said if you had opened the correct case “Not as described” that sould have got you a refund. Seller knew exactly what they were doing, so it is fraud, not a mistake.
Try your payment provider.