I have been the victim of a scam and eBay don’t seem to be helping me.
Summary: annielloyd76 described a challenging experience after selling a mobile phone and facing a dispute from the buyer, who claimed the phone had a fault and returned an empty jiffy bag instead of the phone. Despite providing evidence including tracking numbers and CCTV footage, eBay refunded the buyer. papso22 and other participants discussed the issue, tagging community managers for assistance and pointing out potential loopholes in eBay's return policy. annielloyd76 expressed frustration with eBay's handling of the situation and considered closing their account after 22 years due to the unresolved issue.
I sold a mobile phone in full working order. Seller kept the device for two days before stating that it had a fault with the camera and demanded a partial refund. I provided photos showing the condition of it before it was placed in its original box and placed in a large Jiffy bag and sent. After some backwards and forwarding and me reaching out to eBay’s customer services he opened a dispute and rested to return the item. I once again spoke to CS and they dealt with the return on my behalf. The tracking issued by them even now states it wasn’t posted so you’ll understand my surprise when eBay refund the buyer after the item was returned. But it wasn’t. After they found in the buyers favour they finally gave me the tracking details and I remembered a small empty Jiffy bag (not big enough for the phone unboxed) had arrived and caused some laughs over Whatapp (with photos) with a friend was ‘the returned phone’ according to the tracking. I have cctv of the postman delivering this empty Jiffy bag and you can clearly see it’s not big enough. EBay have closed the case before hearing my side and reviewing my evidence. I tried to call CS again but the AI assistant won’t put me through as the case is closed. How can I resolve this please?
papso22
MentorAre you saying that the tracking number ebay relied on to issue the refund was not the tracking number associated with the return label that was issued in the case? That would be very unusual.
There is a way to deal with wrong item returned scams but you have to act immediately you receive the wrong item as it requires reporting to Report Fraud online and reporting the buyer to freeze the refund while ebay considers the case. As this is post refund you are probably too late.
annielloyd76
OPThe tracking number on eBay doesn’t match the tracking number issued to me by eBay that states that it’s been returned. I hadn’t realised there was an issue with this order as I thought it hadn’t yet been returned.
papso22
MentorThat's odd as they should go by the tracking for the label issued in the case. However if the buyer has persuaded them that they used another delivery service and that shows delivery to you, that will be why they got the refund.
It's extremely sneaky to combine this with returning something else and so stop you being able to use any seller protection.
I will tag the community managers but they might not be able to help here.
@marco@ebay @kat@ebay @dave@ebay
annielloyd76
OPTracking number taken from returns is VX612650486GB and states return not yet posted. Tracking on empty jiffy was VU721290925GB buyers delivery address was Illford, London. Empty Jiffy was posted in Reading with the return address as mine same as delivery address which is why I didn’t see the connection until eBay gave me the further tracking number. A loophole in eBays returns policy that’s clearly be exploited.
tommystrezures
MentorThats helpful and hopefully one of the community managers will be able to advice or assist.
annielloyd76
OPI have managed to speak to CS again and they have escalated it for review. Now I just have to wait up to 7 working days for an outcome. Wouldn’t except my proofs though so I’m not holding out much hope.
red_magpie
MentorThis situation shows how shameful it is that because of the way eBay has structured its affairs the money back guarantee is not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. (All that's regulated is the handling of buyer's payments.)
It's shocking that sellers should have to rely on "hoping" that someone at eBay may listen to them, with no right to any independent appeal if the don't.
It's so unfair that buyers seem to have multiple layers of appeal, through their payment providers, the Consumer Credit Act or the Financial Ombudsman. Sellers have none.
annielloyd76
OPI have had eBay for 22 years and NEVER had an issue, the buyer has been a member since August 2026! And his feedback indicates an issues with another member however they managed to resolve it. Currently has feedback of 9! I hate that you cannot leave negative feedback anymore and automatic feedback too, it defeats the whole object of feedback as you can’t see what a buyer/seller is actually like. I will be closing my account as soon as this is resolved.