Email sent and return as wrong dept
Summary: annielloyd76 shared their experience of selling an iPhone 14 Pro Max on an online marketplace. They detailed a dispute with a buyer who claimed the phone's camera was faulty and demanded a partial refund. Despite providing evidence of the phone's condition and contacting the marketplace for support, a refund was issued after an empty package was allegedly returned. annielloyd76 expressed frustration with the handling of the situation and perceived fraud, seeking a resolution and clarity on preventing similar issues.
To whom this may concern,
I have been an ebay member for 22 years without a problem on any transactions and have feedback of 466 to show that although I am not a regular user I am a consistently good one.
I decided to sell my old iphone 14 Pro Max which was in full working order despite the back glass being cracked. So on 20th September I took numerous photos not all of which were added to the listing before putting it in its box along with a charging cable and information booklet, where it stayed until it was won.
27th September the phone sold for £244.71p. The buyer messaged immediately and asked I posted it the very next day which I did. Posting to Ilford in London.
28th Sept parcelled posted and buyer informed tracking was now live.
30th September Phone was delivered to buyer.
2nd October Funds were released and withdrawn.
2nd October buyer message stating the screen had spots on it when the camera was open and asking for a £30 partial refund, he send pictures of an iphone screen with what can only be described as grease marks on it. I messaged back immediately sharing a photo of the screen with the camera open taken moments before it was boxed. Please see image.
I asked the buyer why he had not checked the item upon receipt and in fact waited days. he did not reply.
I requested a clear photo of the camera lense.
I
I did some research and google informed me that you either have a working or broken camera, the issue described cannot be intermittent. I shared my findings with the buyer asking if he could see my confusion.
He resent the same two photos above of a phone screen with greasy looking blobs.
He stated he would make a youtube video which I was against but he did anyway and it was inconclusive as the phone was continuously moving so nothing could be seen. This video has since been taken down so I cannot share it with you.
this was the next message from the buyer which I now see is a screen shot of a Google search but during the time I was confused and asked him which images had I sent with these dark fuzzy spots. He didn't reply.
I asked again for a clear photo of the camera lenses, The one I received isn't clear and I couldn't conclude anything from it.
He then resent the same photo as before this time with circles around the blobs.
During this time I called ebay for advise, as the buyer hadn't reached out to them they couldn't help but stated if i could prove it wasn't broken all would be resolved.
I asked for a clearer photo of the lenses, he replied 'it's nothing to do with the leans its camera inside is damaged.' This is of course what I was trying to see. Two further images were sent
I stated again that these weren't clear images that I couldn't understand how my images were clear and his were not. I told him his video was blurry and inconclusive. I offered a £15 partial refund to deal with the situation as I was nursing my sick child after surgery.
He replied cost 30£ or i'm happy to return it. I was naive and thought because the listing stated no returns I didn't have to do this and told him so.
I called Ebay again on 3rd October who stated he had now raised an issue, that I had to receive a return as it was not as stated and that they would deal with the return and refund as I had already withdrawn and spent the funds. I was told to examine the phone on its return and report anything different immediately. I wasn't entirely happy but was relieved to have ebays support.
Tracking issued by ebay is VX612650486GB which to this very day has not been posted.
On 8th October I return home to a small (size 0) jiffy bag addressed to me. i open it nd it's completely empty. I share a joke with a friend. TRack the parcels original start point for clues as to its origin and it was posted in Reading. I couldn't work it out and thought little more of it.
Screenshot 2026-10-27 at 06.51.57.png
I did note the weight of the package as 100g and the sender PAYING £2.90 to send it. The return address is the same as the delivery address.
On the 14th October I received an email from ebay stating that as the buyer had returned the item a full refund had been issued. Wait what returned the item??? The tracking stated the item hadn't been sent and the item hadn't been received. I tried to call ebay but because the case was closed it wouldn't connect me. I emailed and asked for the tracking number stating that I had CCTV at my property and could prove it hadn't been returned. The tracking number given was VU721290925GB. I went strat online and was shown an image of a small jiffy bag hanging from my letterbox.
Clearly this is not a boxed iphone. I emailed ebay at once and got a reply that the stand by their refund.
I checked my CCTV and you can clearly see from the images that are time and date stamped the item is too small. I shared my findings with ebay.
I was advised how to speak with a colleague and did so. He explained it would be escalated and could take seven working days to reply.
The reply was they stand by the decision to refund.
The buyer had feedback of 5 when he bid on my device, something that made me feel uneasy from the off. He now has feedback of 10 which includes one stating that an issue was resolved! When reviewing our messages it states "This user cannot receive messages because their account has been suspended or terminated. Please use caution before taking further action" Surely this isn't purely based on my complaints and comments otherwise you wouldn't have found in his favor.
I have reported this as fraud to the police.
Is it just me that can see the 'buyer' has played the system and clearly committed fraud. Ebay have been little help from the start, why do these loopholes exist and what is being done to bridge them?
I have tried to complain to eBay but they simply don’t listen. I would appreciate somebody taking a serious look at this complaint and hope it will be dealt with appropriately. I too would like answers to my questions regarding how this happened and what is being done to stop others from being the victim of this same fraud.