Buyer falsely claiming item is not as described – where is eBay's seller protection?
Summary: melkir25 shared an experience where a buyer falsely claimed an item was not as described due to fit issues, despite accurate listing details. After initially being told they must accept the return, melkir25 contacted eBay, provided video evidence, and successfully had the return request canceled, with funds released. Other participants questioned the effectiveness of video evidence, with mixed opinions on its usefulness. melkir25 defended their use of video to prevent false claims, citing past experiences in their family.
I recently sold a top, and the buyer has opened an "Item not as described" return request, claiming the item feels too small. However, the item was accurately advertised, and the sizing matches the manufacturer's label exactly. The buyer received precisely what was described. Their complaint is about personal fit, not an inaccurate listing.
I also have full video evidence of the item being packaged, clearly showing its condition and the manufacturer's sizing label.
I contacted eBay customer service, but they told me I must accept the return simply because the buyer selected "Item not as described", despite acknowledging that I had advertised the correct size.
I'm struggling to understand how this is fair to sellers. eBay's Seller Protection and Abusive Buyer policies prohibit false "Item not as described" claims, yet it seems buyers can use this reason to bypass a seller's no-returns policy.
EDIT: For anyone else dealing with the situation, called up eBay, explained the situation and the evidence I had, and they cancelled the buyer's return request and released my funds immediately.
tressygirl
MentorThe reason why eBay have never and will not accept ' video' evidence of items being packed, as there can be no 100% certainty that will be the exact item to be posted.
Never bother videoing items, waste of time.
@melkir25
melkir25
OPI just got off the phone with eBay, explained the situation and the evidence I had, and they cancelled the buyer's return request and released my funds immediately. So I'm very glad I took the precaution of recording everything!
tressygirl
MentorThey probably made a discretionary refund to the buyer and released your funds, it happens, which is great, but your video evidence would have played no part, they never request this, they never look at any.
@melkir25
papso22
MentorWhy would you video the item being packed? Seems OTT for a private seller.
To answer your question, you can report the buyer for misuse of the money back guarantee once you get the item back.
melkir25
OPTo protect myself against dishonest idiots who makes false claims about items being damaged or not as described. My mum was an eBay seller for over 10 years, so I'm well aware of how often these things can happen. I'd rather have evidence than be left with no way to defend myself.
But will reporting the buyer actually achieve anything? I've already paid the original postage, and now I'm being forced to pay return postage too, despite the item being accurately described.