What do you think of the new boards?
Summary: The discussion revolves around the new changes to an online board system, with participants expressing mixed feelings. rare_treat highlights pros and cons, noting improved AI summaries but issues with post visibility due to a new "Pending approval" status. apolloslots mentions frustration with pagination and missing or delayed discussions, but appreciates faster loading times. There are concerns about AI functionality, with bidicus*maximus criticizing the removal of features like private messaging and kudos. cee-dee experiences technical glitches and acknowledges issues with notifications and inaccurate last post timestamps. insidethe93 expresses dissatisfaction with AI summaries, suggesting improvements or removal.
I suppose that as soon as something changes, people will say they don't like it?
Some will say they like this or that but.............
OK, so what DON'T you like and what DO you like?
Any takers?
cee-dee
OPIt's changed again and is saying that "the debate revolves around the new characteristics etc etc"
repairexpert
This takes the biscuit; just went to my group and the AI box has just changed to Spanish. LOL!
repairexpert
Now gone back to English after a couple of posts. Ebay please dump this Summary AW box; it's awful and meaningless.
repairexpert
Back to Spanish again now. :(
subminman
Having played with the community boards for another day please get rid of the Ai summary, it serves no useful purpose. Is it a case of we bought Ai and we are going to use it everywhere we can?
I am an ex IT developer and sometimes you just have to say no.....
bidicus*maximus
I noticed just now that so far only 2 people have "joined" and become "members". I can see the excuse that, "there aren't enough members", being used to close the board entirely. I'd like to suggest that anyone reading this should go ahead and push the "join" button, if they haven't already and are against seeing this happen.
Of course, it's possible that I'm just being paranoid...
repairexpert
At least one question I've been concerned with answered by Google...
"Yes, eBay community group posts and discussion boards are completely visible to the general public. You do not need to be an eBay member or logged into an account to read the posts. Only registered, logged-in eBay members can create posts, join groups, or reply to existing discussions."
Now the AI Summary , which started out giving a reasonable summary of the group. has started producing Gobbledegook and even changing the user names of the people posting into a mixture of random letters and numbers. I think the Summary is the first thing that needs to go.
insidethe93
Today I see the AI anonymises member's IDs - I think that's a good idea! unless your name/ID is actually mxxv7j. As long as it confines that to the AI Summary.
repairexpert
Think I may be missing something; what advantage is there in changing the users ID's when the threads below contain the correct ID's all of which are all viewable by the general public?
insidethe93
It may encourage people to go straight to the posts. I'm not sure the AI needs to mention specific people anyway, anonymised or not.
I've posted a complaint or two about the AI diluting my complaint which undermined my post. I'd rather the AI wasn't there or didn't try to speak for me (as it can't do it right). Since the AI is there, at least if it anonymises my ID then I can't be associated with AI's words, at least not immediately; and people, if they happen on my post, can then assess it from what I actually say. Not just re me - I noticed that AI was doing this with other members too. At the least it's spoilers, and not in a good way.
I agree with @repairexpert that the AI is one of the first things that should go. Or it should be very vastly improved. It's unnecessary to say the least. Or give an option to Hide it or to click away to it. Somewhere someone in the last day or so pointed out the AI summary was longer than their post.
In an earlier thread a member mentioned about AI (not that accurately) summarising a post and giving the poster's ID, reckoning there could be or (or would be?) "complaints about it". I'm unable to locate that thread and post; ironically the new layout doesn't help as I bet I could've found it under the old layout. So, yes, I'm one of those "complaining about it". P.S. took ages but I found it! @technthread in the thread "THE NEW PLATFORM - FOR BETTER OR WORSE?" Adding the P.S. has shown me we can now edit posts hours/day later which we couldn't previously. I'm not sure whether to quote technthread, don't want to step on any toes, but that post and that thread are worth a look if you haven't already seen it.
repairexpert
While I would agree that the old boards were perhaps a little outdated the new ones could have been better designed. Apart from some of the senseless comments of the AI Summary box, one of my members had a post rejected by AI for no apparent reason. Letting AI moderate instead of a human is a bad mistake; AI makes errors; it's not perfect.
One of my biggest objections is the fact of privacy. On the old system only members of the group could see posts; now it's the entire World. How long before spammers and scammers find a way of making use of things some people post; especially those members who are daft enough to give names, addresses, etc. in their posts? Be careful what you post.
jonatjonatjonat
The old boards were also publicly viewable as far as I'm aware.
cee-dee
OPHow many more faults will come to light? Like if you mark all notifications as read, then try to go back, nothing happens, you have to click "eBay café" or "Home" at the top of the page and although notifications are "off" they still turn up!
insidethe93
Just 4 complaints, rather than detail them all!
Nested conversations - it's Nuts. Discussed here and in other threads.
The AI - Absolutely Inane. (Also discussed elsewhere in the boards.) Its native language is Bland. AI is designed to dilute, de-fang and de-humanise. At least give us the option to Hide it. Yes you can scroll past it, just like you can (i.e. have to) scroll past a lot of things including flippin' adverts on your orders page. Also, AI tends to read literally so we have to be careful when expressing the human fortes of sarcasm and humour.
The tiny font. It's unnecessarily small. Yet the adverts and sidebars are in normal font and look huge. The Messages/Categories/Subscriptions sidebar takes up an excesssive 20% of the page width!
The emojis. A single uptick like before is all that's needed. Having several uptick symbols divides and dilutes, in the same way that in elections having more than one left- or right-wing candidate splits the left- and right-wing vote.
repairexpert
If your text is too small you can set minimu sizes on a computer...
Open Settings (press
Click Accessibility on the left menu.
Select Text Size.
insidethe93
@cee-dee wrote "A fault with the new format is that now and again the boards don't respond. I get a blank page with "Something went wrong please try again" and underneath, "Try again". = same result before you get "504, gateway timeout""
Same here. Almost every post. Refreshing the page usually works, second time if not the first. It wouldn't be eBay without glitches, so we know which site we're on :-)
bidicus*maximus
It looks to me like these latest changes were intentionally created to kill the boards. While they said in advance that some features would no longer be present, the ones that are gone are all of the best ones. No private messages. No ability to choose a post as a solution (which killed several games on the AU boards). No kudos (also useful in games)... and with the replacement for that, the thumbs up, etc., you can give one to yourself and you also can't see who it was that left it for you. No more count of thread views... a very simple thing to provide. While I like being able to see when the last post was made without opening the thread, I miss being able to see the name of the poster who made it.
What else, if anything, do you miss and wish that they would bring back?
cee-dee
OPSomething I've noticed, where it says when a thread was last posted on on some threads it was way, way off.
The choons thread it said it was last posted on a year ago, cobblers.
The original (from the Round Table) Good Morning thread it said was last posted on 3 months ago, cobblers. Me and Petal posted there the day before the boards went read only.
LOADS of recent posts on those threads were removed before they picked a "start point".
The other GM thread was from the Family, Home & Garden board as is the ALL NEW competition thread. What more will come to light?
subminman
Why do we have an Ai summary that is as big or even bigger than the actual post! Look at this post as an example. Do we even need an Ai summary at all!
messier44000
Beta testing for Ai weekly chat replies
cee-dee
OPSomething that doesn't work. If I click "the bell" at the top right, see the notifications (that I can't seem to stop even though they're at "off") and click "mark all as read", if I then try to go back (click the arrow top left) it won't "go back". To get back here I use my favourite link.
repairexpert
The layout is pretty clean and easy to use; why they send you, many hours later, an email saying your post has been approve is a mystery to me.
However there appears to be no members list but seems to be open to everyone. Whether this means just ebay members or the general public (which would be a little concerning) is a mystery. Confirmation would be appreciated. At least we're back. :)
cee-dee
OPA fault with the new format is that now and again the boards don't respond. I get a blank page with "Something went wrong please try again" and underneath, "Try again". = same result before you get "504, gateway timeout"
It's nothing to do with my connection or system because everything else opens in a flash.
cee-dee
OPYes, I think using the "comment" box rather than "reply" puts the post at the top of the thread.
apolloslots
The pagination isn't particularly great for me. 10 topics or so then click to page 2 and 3,etc and so on. Seems a step back to me. Whereas before you could simply 'load more'. The 'selling board', which I used the most previously, doesn't list all the latest discussions under that link - have to click through to subforums - where before you you could view all under this meta-forum category. I'm not necessarily saying this is a step backwards, as loading is faster and probably other things I haven't noticed are likely improved. But with the 4-5 days to implement and test it feels as if more testing should have been done.
Also a test comment regarding @jonatjonatjonat comment about threaded replies: I have used the 'comment' box up top, not the reply, to see if this is threaded or not.
rare_treat
At the moment I can see both pros and cons.
I think we need more time to get used to it and wage a proper opinion.
A positive I just experienced was the the AI summary of my new topic was pretty spot on. The negative is that I still can't see it in the list - a new "Pending approval" status seems to be the reason!
cee-dee
OPI see that usually the last post is now at the top of the posts on a thread, but sometimes I've seen that the last post is "one down" from the top???? Why's that??
jonatjonatjonat
Nested Replies. While in this case - this post was the last reply - its nested under one of the already existing replies to the thread - if you notice - the replies nest under each other.