eBay's INR Policy Is Unfair – Why Must Sellers Refund Before Royal Mail Declares an Item Lost?
Summary: The discussion centers on the challenges small business sellers face with eBay's Item Not Received (INR) policy, particularly regarding Royal Mail's delayed deliveries. uppergrounddecals highlights the financial burden on sellers due to eBay allowing buyers to open INR cases before Royal Mail considers items lost. Other participants, including boundarycoins and sml192, contribute by discussing eBay's focus on buyer retention and the impracticality of resolving delivery issues before Royal Mail's official lost-item acknowledgment. Some participants share similar experiences and express concerns about the unsustainability of current practices, advocating for policies that align with postal service timelines. Issues like low-value item sales, rising costs, and postal inefficiencies are also discussed, with suggestions for better seller protection and different business strategies being proposed.
eBay, how exactly is your Item Not Received policy fair to small business sellers?
Royal Mail doesn't consider a 2nd Class item officially lost until 10 working days after its expected delivery date. Yet eBay allows buyers to open an Item Not Received case shortly after the estimated delivery date and potentially escalate it just 3 business days later.
How does that make any sense?
You're expecting sellers to refund customers for items that Royal Mail hasn't even officially declared lost!
We pay eBay fees, promotional fees, postage costs, packaging costs and taxes, yet when Royal Mail delays or misdelivers an item, it's the seller who gets punished financially.
Royal Mail gets paid, the buyer gets refunded, if we mess about with delaying the INR then ebay also get paid and the small business seller is left out of pocket through no fault of their own.
I'm not suggesting genuine buyers shouldn't be protected. Of course they should. But where is the protection for honest sellers who have dispatched their orders correctly?
Why doesn't eBay's INR policy take Royal Mail's official lost-item timescales into account?
You claim to support small businesses, yet your policies increasingly make selling low-value products financially unsustainable.
Small sellers shouldn't be expected to absorb every failure of a delivery service they've already paid for.
nigel_paul_wright7557
I recently had a INR on an item I sold.
Ebay said refund before 27th September.
On 23rd September the buyer escalated the claim and ebay marked me down with a strike.
This is grossly unfair.
santlache_sales
Royal Mail don't want anyone to send Second Class anymore, so they give it totally unreasonable delays.
I have sent two letters 2nd Class recently, not ebay or important and one took eight days to arrive, the other ten days to arrive. This is an appalling service, yet ebay use these so-called made-up delivery times which simply don't exist.
People have been complaining about ebay's stupid postage policy for years, I'm afraid this will also fall on deaf ears like all the others, ebay simply aren't interested in fairness or the fact Royal Mail are failing.
never_defeated
I note below a comment below about having to refund 6 days after due date - 3 days for delivery and then 3 days for the claim. If the days fall wrongly it is possible that only one window for delivery has been missed as delivery is only every other day now and most buyers are not aware of this (although some chancers are!) With delivery Mon, Weds, Fri then Tues, Thurs and nothing happening at weekends. So a Thursday posting would probably go; Thurs posted, Friday "received" by PO, Monday in transit, Tues - not a delivery day. Delivery Wednesday. If the Wednesday window is missed that puts it on the Friday delivery so theoretically a refund is due if they are hot with the INR. There may be worse scenarios but Thursday does not look good!!
pillarboxred
I think eBay's plan is to be more like Amazon. So the businesses it wants are huge warehouses with automated processing. Our days are numbered here.
happy-comfy-homes
I had the same issues but I charge full postage now and charge for returns. With all the huge charges from eBay plus refunds I could not cope some items I am not selling any more because I have increased the prices. I sell more on other platforms with no charges for items that I took off eBay.
Royal Mail are increasing prices ahead of the season and Black Friday. Royal refused to reimburse me for package they lost or delivered two weeks later for and item that was posted tracked.
People are complaining for the postage price but that is the charge.
ebay does no have seller covered it is all about the buyers only.
watchfan700uk
This is why I set my shipping to 10 day dispatch. It hardly affected sales when I did it and now I get very few INRs because nobody can open one for a good 2 weeks - by which time the stragglers have all arrived. Simple.
uppergrounddecals
OPToday I've finally had enough and decided to make some drastic changes to my eBay business.
I've cancelled my £34 monthly shop subscription, reduced my catalogue from almost 200 listings to just 34 of my best sellers, and increased my prices to include free Royal Mail Tracked 48 delivery.
If nothing sells, then so be it. I'm past caring about chasing sales at rock-bottom prices just to make a few pennies after eBay fees, advertising, postage, materials and tax.
Second Class postage is no longer a sustainable option for me. The delays, INR claims and pressure to refund customers for problems completely outside my control have made selling cheap decals more trouble than they're worth.
The reality is that you can't keep absorbing rising costs, offering free postage and competing with sellers charging next to nothing while expecting to run a profitable business.
I've spent years building my business, but sales and earnings have declined to the point where I seriously considered closing it altogether.
So rather than completely walk away, I've stripped everything back, introduced a small multi-buy offer and decided to concentrate on quality, reliable tracked delivery and actually earning something worthwhile for my time.
I'd rather sell fewer items at a sensible profit than work twice as hard for next to nothing.
Maybe the changes will work, maybe they'll kill what's left of my sales. Either way, I'm done constantly lowering prices and changing postage policies just to chase orders.
I'll give it 30 days and see what happens.
If customers aren't prepared to pay a realistic price that covers the costs of making and delivering a product, then perhaps those sales simply aren't worth having.
Small businesses aren't charities, and being busy means absolutely nothing if there's no money left at the end of it.
maarsy
parcels ofc now are cheaper to send tracked , but i had my share of issues with large letters . it seems to be worth selling them with 2 nd class postage to make a few quid but not quite worth it to send them tracked . in one month i had problems with 5 out of 8 items , I asked the customers to hold on for a few days explaining postal issues , only 1 had to be refunded .
uppergrounddecals
OPYou're lucky then.
Last month, when my INR claims really started taking off, I was messaging buyers asking them to allow a few extra days because Royal Mail's delivery performance was getting ridiculous.
Did it work? Sometimes. But others would open an INR the moment their estimated delivery date had passed.
What was I supposed to do? Keep messaging them every day?
"Has it arrived yet?"
Next day: "Has it arrived yet?"
I simply don't have the time to chase every single buyer because Royal Mail can't deliver something within a reasonable timeframe.
If eBay's claims process actually worked alongside Royal Mail's delayed and lost-item policy, sellers would at least have a realistic opportunity to investigate the delivery and establish whether the 2D barcode had been scanned.
Here's a real example. I posted an item on 24 June. It eventually arrived on 24 July. A FULL MONTH later! God only knows where it had been.
Fortunately, that particular buyer was lovely and understanding. But let's face it, not every buyer is like that. Some are complete __________ (fill in the blanks yourself).
And that's my point. This is no way to run an e-commerce business. We shouldn't have to rely on the goodwill and patience of buyers, or be forced to issue refunds because a delivery company has failed to do its job within eBay's strict timeframe.
Something needs to change. At the very least, eBay's INR resolution process needs to take Royal Mail's actual delivery and lost-item timescales into account, rather than expecting sellers to resolve problems before Royal Mail will even investigate them.
Or am I completely mad? Should I just leave it to fate and hope I get a patient buyer every time Royal Mail loses or delays something?
c_of_e84
Royal Mail are official Ebay partners, there fully integrated, how can this happen (Easily and often)
uppergrounddecals
OPSmall items used to be my bread and butter. Selling them for £3.89 with free postage worked perfectly well. I had the occasional Item Not Received (INR) claim, but nothing worth worrying about.
Now Royal Mail has completely destroyed Second Class delivery times. I know this because I'm a full-time postman. In my own delivery office, I regularly see Second Class mail sitting in sorting frames for four days or more before being delivered. Not every delivery is affected, but enough are, and there's no consistency. It's ridiculous.
To get around this, I increased my prices to £5.99 plus £1.95 postage, allowing me to send everything using Tracked 48.
The result? My sales have practically died over the last four weeks.
I simply cannot compete with sellers offering similar products for £2.99 or £3.99 with free postage.
I originally assumed that buyers repeatedly opening INR claims would eventually have those claims flagged against their accounts. What I hadn't fully appreciated was just how badly these claims could also affect my own seller metrics.
So I'm now stuck in a ridiculous situation.
I increase my prices to cover tracked postage, which reduces my exposure to INR claims, but nobody buys anything because I'm too expensive. Technically, that solves the INR problem because I have no sales!
Alternatively, I price my products competitively using Second Class postage, knowing full well that some letters will sit in Royal Mail sorting frames for days before delivery. That's not speculation; I see it happening with my own eyes at work.
I've now had to revert one category in my eBay shop back to lower prices with free postage, just to give myself a chance of making sales again.
But that means I'm exposing myself to the same INR problems all over again.
So what exactly am I supposed to do?
Price my items high enough to use tracked postage and watch my sales disappear, or price them competitively and risk eBay penalising me for delivery failures that are completely outside my control?
Either way, the small seller loses.
boundarycoins
I’m guessing a lot of us heard the recent story about letters being ‘taken for a walk’ as well so we are aware of it.
Maybe take this with a pinch of salt as I don’t know your category but I’d look to increase prices and promote. I hate to say that but I’d rather that than a race to the bottom.
uppergrounddecals
OPI tried to raise prices to allow for Tracked 48 at £2.90 ,i did not raise the promo %, i give ebay enough as it is, and like i said in a previous reply. yes its fixed my INR but only because i have hardly any sales.
I sell decals and van signs, using proffessional gear, not a cricut or whatever these hobby cutters are called.
I bought a sellers cheap decal, and yes it was cheap and nasty, the offset was terrible,and its that quality of decal that us sellers with proper gear are forced to compete with.
A buyer doesnt see quality and materials used, they only see the price.
I think i may be in the wrong niche.
For now i stick with low price, free postage, if INR go throught he roof again i may be forced to ditch low value items altogehter as its not work the stress.
ebay have not raised the buisness shop prices up for quite some time, so that will be next you see. and the reason for the raise will be to impove shareholder dividends, sorry slip of tongue, i mean to improve their platform.
c_of_e84
You wouldnt have this problem if you were a business seller masquerading as a private seller using simple delivery, just an observation !
sml192
In short. because the buyers entitlement to a refund is not reliant on the outcome of your claim with the carrier.
I do agree though that eBay could perhaps make buyers wait a little longer before being able to open a claim, especially given how over optimistic eBay's estimated delivery dates often are.
uppergrounddecals
OPThere would be no need to refund if ebay set a 10 working day minimum waiting before claims can be made.
If royal mail do not class and item as lost until 10 working days for 2nd class, then why should ebay sellers be forced to refund 6 days after item is shipped, so thats 3 days estimated delivey, then 3 days after claim is made to sort out?
Irs makes no sense , and shows the incompetence of people running this ebay, they cant even get policys lined up with couriers .
papso22
Ebay's policies are not written to be fair to sellers.
boundarycoins
The problem would be the buyer would wait 3-4 weeks for a resolution. Even though we can claim from RM after 10 working days it can take another week to get the letter through the post with the book of stamps or a cheque if we are lucky. It would be unfair on the buyer to sit in limbo for so long. It also pushes things very close on the 30 day eBay MBG and there would be sellers who will deliberately try to time buyers out.
eBay would also be concerned that after one experience where the buyer waits a long time for their money back they will never come back and eBay lose all future revenue from them. In short they care much more about retaining buyers than sellers so we just have to suck it up. It is another reason why I would like simple delivery which the private sellers get.
uppergrounddecals
OPI agree that making buyers wait 3–4 weeks for a resolution wouldn't be fair either. But surely there has to be a better system than simply making the seller take the financial hit every time Royal Mail fails to deliver on time.
Perhaps eBay could temporarily cover the refund when an INR case is escalated, then allow the seller time to establish whether the item is genuinely lost. If it's confirmed lost, the seller could reimburse eBay and pursue compensation through Royal Mail. I'm not saying that's a perfect solution, and I'm not entirely sure how it would work in practice, but surely a company the size of eBay could come up with something fairer.
eBay is understandably concerned about losing buyers, but what about losing sellers? If small businesses continually lose money through delivery problems beyond their control, eventually they'll either stop selling low-value items or leave the platform altogether.
Without sellers, eBay doesn't have a marketplace. Buyer protection is important, but seller protection should matter just as much. At the moment, it feels like all the responsibility and financial risk are being pushed onto the seller.
boundarycoins
I do sympathise as I’ve been stung by it. The way I get my head round it is by the time an INR needs dealing with if there is no delivery scan it’s probably not going to get one anyway.
I think they have already pushed the low value items away tbh. I’ve been listing today and got 1 item on eBay for £9.99. The rest has been going up for sale elsewhere. Looking at live listings there was so much competition for the items buyers had choice here so it would have to be a massive exodus of sellers for them to take notice. I don’t follow eBay’s financials but don’t their profits keep rising year on year.
sml192
Ebay does now reimburse sellers if an item is delivered within 30 days of a refund being issued but, unfortunately, only if the postage is purchased through eBay and a tracked service is used.
uppergrounddecals
OPYes, that's correct, and it works well for items sent using a tracked service. Unfortunately, it's a different story when you're selling low-cost items that rely on Second Class postage.
My smaller items are now priced at £3.89 with free postage. If I were to use Tracked 48 at £2.90, then deduct eBay's 13% fees, another 10% in promoted listing fees, VAT where applicable, materials, electricity and packaging costs, I'd be practically giving the items away for free.
There's simply no profit left.
Tracked postage might be a sensible solution for higher-value items, but it isn't financially viable for products selling at £3.89.
That's the problem small sellers are facing. We're expected to provide reliable delivery, absorb increasing postage costs, compete with rock-bottom prices and take responsibility when Royal Mail fails to deliver on time.
At some point, the numbers simply stop adding up.
Ive looked at these race to the bottom sellers, they are litterly making 10p profits, so they either have no idea how to run a shop, dont value their own time, or really are low IQ.
Now i understand sell low get buyers in the shop maybe they buy more, i cant say i ever had many buyer buy cheap items from me and treat themselves to a larger item,nor that i can think of right now.
So i have gone back to lower my items with free postage and just hope that they turn up.
If not i may as well shut up shop,and persue a different side hustle.
I started this for fun and some extra pennies to put food on the tab;e, not to spend hours dealing with INR claims, sellers stealing my designs and having to go through the vero nonsense etc.
jlovie
Does it have to be fully tracked (e.g. T48) or does 2nd class confirmation code count as tracking?
I'm trying to find details of the process in help but can't see anything.
Not that it makes a lot of difference, as I'm seeing a lot of 2nd class LL not getting scanned.
I only find out they're delivered if the buyer leaves feedback.
It's scary looking at how many aren't confirmed delivered, if they all end up INR I guess my account would be toast.
uppergrounddecals
OPTracked 48 provides tracking from the moment an item enters the Royal Mail network, which is great if your products and profit margins allow you to absorb the £2.90 large letter postage cost into the selling price.
Second Class, however, is a completely different story. Royal Mail's Track and Trace website states that delivery information will be updated when a delivery attempt is made, yet in my experience, this rarely happens. I genuinely don't understand the point of having a 2D barcode on these labels if neither the seller nor eBay can reliably establish whether an item has actually been delivered.
eBay needs to introduce a minimum waiting period of 10 working days before an Item Not Received (INR) claim can be escalated, regardless of the delivery method used.
This would give sellers a realistic timeframe that actually works alongside Royal Mail's own lost-item claims policy. It would also allow sellers to contact Royal Mail and establish whether the 2D barcode has been scanned before being forced to issue a refund.
Instead, look at what happens under the current system.
A buyer opens an INR claim because their item hasn't arrived. The seller contacts Royal Mail through its online claims system, only to be told they must wait another four or five working days before they can even submit a claim.
Meanwhile, eBay's deadline to resolve the INR is rapidly approaching. If the seller doesn't refund the buyer or provide acceptable proof of delivery, eBay can step in, force a refund and potentially leave the seller out of pocket for the original selling fees as well.
Then, several days later, Royal Mail finally confirms that the item was delivered. Brilliant! Except the buyer has already been refunded, the seller has lost the money, and all they have is an email stating that the item was delivered.
Delivered where, exactly? The correct house? The wrong street? The wrong postcode? Who knows?
The fundamental problem is that eBay's INR resolution deadlines and Royal Mail's lost-item investigation timescales simply do not work together.
Sellers are expected to resolve delivery problems before Royal Mail will even allow them to investigate properly. That's completely unreasonable, particularly for small businesses selling low-value products where tracked postage can swallow most of the profit.
I'm not suggesting buyers should be left waiting indefinitely or denied legitimate refunds. I'm saying the system needs a fair and realistic timeframe that protects both parties.
Right now, the seller carries almost all the financial risk for a delivery service they have absolutely no control over once the item enters the postal network.
It's a complete mess, and both eBay and Royal Mail need to address it.
c_of_e84
Tracked 48 provides tracking from the moment an item enters the Royal Mail network.
WRONG !
If you send using RM48 and Royal Mail collect from you for 50p, scan the item on the doorstep and send you an email 30 seconds later this does NOT count as dispatched, Ebay do NOT count it as dispatched even though its illegal under Royal Mail regulations to ask a postal operative for an item back after they have it n there possession and thats from Royal Mail security.
uppergrounddecals
OPI WORK FOR ROYAL MAIL AS SOON AS I SCAN MY ITEMS THEY ARE ON THE SYSTEM. (item recived 07.48)
ask me if you want facts, does security know.